Saturday, June 1, 2024

Trumped-Up Charges?

What exactly was Trump found guilty of?

I am glad that I was not a juror on the Trump trial, as the charges - as reported by the mainstream media - seemed rather vague.  "Falsifying Business Records" seems like an odd felony, particularly when the profit from it, if any, is slim.

I mean, I get it, from a tax perspective.  If you claim a hush-money payment to a porn star as a "legal expense" then you might be defrauding the IRS or the NYS tax authorities.  But in the greater scheme of things, the lost tax revenue on an fraudulent $130,000 deduction might be, at most, $30K in Federal and State taxes, if that. And I suppose one could argue that if your business was being a reality television star, that paying $130K for a "non-disclosure agreement" is part and parcel of your "business" of selling your image - because, let's face it, that's all Trump is, an image sold on the Internets.

I am sure they will raise that issue on appeal.

Of course, New York is the home of Wall Street and the largest trading platform in the world.  It is important for publicly-traded companies not to falsify business records, lest investors be snookered by such lies.   Better off to hype your stock on Reddit/wallstreetbets because that's legal, right?  But the point is moot as the "Trump Organization" is privately held and if anyone is being defrauded (other than the IRS), it is Trump defrauding himself.

I mean, who is getting hurt here?  Some argue that this hush-money payment, made days before the election, turned the election in Trump's favor.  Perhaps, but I recall at the time hearing about the Stormy Daniels tryst as well as a host of dirt on Trump, who like a bad penny has been turning up since the days of the Trump Princess, the Trump Casinos, and the Trump Shuttle - all of which he lost due to incompetence and overpaying for.

But being a shitty businessman is not a crime and the sort of intelligentsia who watches "reality teevee" thought he was a big boss-man who hired and fired people on a whim (instead of a reality teevee star playing at being a big boss-man).  Those idiots would have voted for him either way - and still support him to this day.  Even the "evangelicals" support him, as they want to see the rise of the Anti-Christ so the end times will be moved along more quickly.

No, I don't buy the election thing.  He didn't win - Hillary lost.  And by the way, after losing the nomination to Obama in 2008, why was she deemed the "presumptive nominee" sixteen years after her husband left office?  The Democrats nominated the wrong candidate - an empty suit could have beat Trump in 2016 - but not a pantsuit.

As a "first-time offender" (first-time caught, anyway) he likely won't see jail time but will see a fairly hefty fine - paid in full by the GOP finance committee.  The end result will be.... nothing.  Well, nothing other than to embolden his followers and get out the vote for GOP candidates down-ballot.

Hitler came to power only after a failed putsch.  He spent his time in jail writing a book and made himself into a martyr which served only to increase his popularity.  When the government "suppresses" something, it only serves to increase the curiosity of the masses, as everyone loves a bad boy and wants to see what is being withheld from them.

This whole thing could backfire in a spectacular way for the Democrats.

I mean, I get it - the only thing they could nail Al Capone for was tax evasion.  But no one really liked Al Capone - not even his associates.  He killed people and despite the media's fascination with gangsters (it sells newspapers - and today, eyeballs) most folks simply didn't give a shit when he got put away.  You live by the sword, you die by the sword.

But politicians are a different animal. Believe it or not, some folks actually like Trump, or at least the image of him they were sold.  They also are vehemently against what the right-wing media has painted as the platform of the Democratic Party.  According to Fox News, the most burning issue facing America today is transgender bathrooms.  Sadly, some on the far-left agree, along with defending Hamas, which is a terrorist organization.

Of course, Trump is still facing charges - far more serious charges - for his interference in the 2020 election. Sadly, it doesn't look like those will even get to trial before the election.  So we have this rinky-dink "win" that people can rightfully piss on as much ado about nothing - and then bootstrap to pooh-pooh the more serious crimes he committed.

Choose your battles wisely.  Election fraud? Yes! But why did it take nearly three years to bring these charges?  Falsifying business records?  More like a technical foul.   And a case that will only embolden Trump and the MAGA set.

This was a missed opportunity with potentially catastrophic consequences.

Friday, May 31, 2024

Hybrids, Plug-In Hybrids, and EVs - Not the Same Thing! (Not Even Close!)

Hybrids are nothing like EVs and don't operate like you think they would.

There is a misconception about hybrid cars, plug-in hybrids, and EVs.  A lot of people think a hybrid car is an "electric car" that has an IC range extender, or is an electric car that recharges its batteries using an IC engine.

False and sort-of false.

As we learned at GMI, a car traveling along a level highway at 60 MPH uses very little energy.  An engine of less than 20 HP would push a Buick at that speed, and I'm talking old-school Roadmasters, too.  It is only in climbing hills or by accelerating that you actually use more energy.  "An object in motion tends to stay in motion, an object at rest tends to remain at rest" - you remember old Sir Issac Newton, right?  And if you know anything about physics, accelerating is like climbing a hill, in a manner of speaking.

So a car on a flat highway, travelling at constant speed needs only that 20HP (or less!) to overcome aerodynamic drag, tire friction, driveline friction, and other parasitic losses.  That's why the guy who weaves in and out of traffic, slamming on his brakes and then flooring it, is not only not making time (and is also endangering all of us) but is wasting a lot of gas.

There are little savings to be had in optimizing a car for highway travel, other than reducing frictional losses and making the car more aerodynamic.  We've done both, with low-rolling-resistance tires and even doing things like putting ATF in the differential to reduce friction - as well as rounding our cars (but not our trucks!) to reduce wind resistance.

It is in the city where gas really gets wasted. Going from stoplight to stoplight involves accelerating (the big gas waster). You hit the throttle to accelerate and the gas consumption goes way up. You step on the brakes to stop at the next stoplight and that energy is converted into heat by the service brakes - wasted into the atmosphere in a cloud of brake dust.

Sure, you can optimize this too, by making the car lighter (F=ma, remember?) or making the engine smaller to limit acceleration.  But that only goes so far and there is so much waste in city driving.

Enter the hybrid.  Not an "electric car" but a way of recovering energy from braking.  A small IC engine is used to propel the car, and when accelerating, an electric motor kicks in to provide the additional energy needed.  When coming to a stoplight or stop sign - and this is key - if you let up on the gas, the electric motor becomes a generator, recharging the battery with the energy ordinarily wasted by the friction service brakes.

The problem is, of course, if you slam on the brakes at the last minute, or accelerate too quickly, the fuel economy goes to hell as the entire plan is foiled.  Accelerate too quickly and instead of using stored electricity to accelerate, you are also using the IC engine.  Wait until the crosswalk to start braking, and the service brake takes over and all that energy gets wasted as heat.

When we lived in Politically Correct Ithaca New York, I met people who had Toyota Priuses (Prii?) as poliitcal statements more than anything else. When I asked them what kind of mileage they were getting, one girl giggled and said, "It'll get 45 but the way I drive, I only get 30!"  Just changing driving habits would increase fuel mileage by 50% and fulfill her PC ambitions - but Nah!  Too busy driving to the environmental protest - right?

A lady sued Honda a few years back, claiming that her Honda hybrid didn't get the advertised gas mileage.  And some stupid judge went along with this and they settled in small claims court.  The truth of the matter is that with any car and in particular with hybrids, your mileage may vary considerably based on how you drive.  You can make a hybrid get 10 MPG by driving like a total ass - that is not the fault of Honda or Toyota.  The defect lies in the nut behind the wheel.

Now a plug-in hybrid is somewhat closer to an electric car, but again is not an electric car with a "range extender" or an electric car that is recharged by its IC engine (although it does do that, of course).  As you might expect, there is no efficiency gained by using an IC engine to charge a battery and then use that energy to run an electric motor.  Maybe that works for locomotives (diesel-electric) where you have to harness thousands of horsepower that an ordinary transmission can't handle.  But for a car, well, it would just make it less efficient as there are losses in every step.

UPDATE:  When the Chevy Volt came out, enthusiasts wrongly thought it was a "series hybrid" - that is to say, it was driven by an electric motor, powered by a battery which was charged by an IC engine.  That was incorrect.  Such an arrangement could work but the efficiency would be horrible, as energy would be lost at each stage of conversion from mechanical to electrical, to chemical, back to electrical, and then back to mechanical. The Volt, like the plug-in Prius was a parallel hybrid, using electrical power to assist in acceleration and then recapturing that energy in regenerative braking (as well as providing a small range through excess battery capacity).  A series hybrid, in retrospect, really would make no sense, outside of railroad locomotives.

A plug-in hybrid functions like a hybrid as discussed above - recapturing energy lost to braking and then adding it when accelerating (which is why hybrids get better mileage in the city than on the highway).  But in addition, you sort of have a little bit of an electric car thrown in.  A reader reports that their plug-in hybrid will go about 12 miles before the engine turns on.  Not a great range, considering that in the EV world, 300 miles is the golden number to hit.  But he reports that for most driving around town, the IC engine never turns on and when he gets home, he can then plug it in and recharge.

I advised him to put STA-BIL in the gas - it will go bad over time, particularly in hot weather as he uses so little of it.

Of course an EV is a pure battery car, and thus relies 100% on electricity to accelerate and then recaptures some of that energy in braking.  Again, drive an EV like a jackalope and you can cut the range very short in no time, as "Hoovie" of "Hoovie's Garage" (YouTube) aptly demonstrated.  What a dork!

But as you can see, while an EV might have a little in common with a plug-in hybrid, it really has nothing in common with a pure hybrid, other than both recapture braking energy (if driven properly). EVs do this to maintain their range.  Hybrids do this to increase gas mileage.  Similar ides, different applications.

Of course, even with a pure IC engine car you can really improve your gas mileage by changing how you drive.  I went to put the trailer away today and was chagrined to see people accelerating toward red lights as if "getting there first" was some kind of achievement or they would win a prize or something. All they were doing was wasting gas and wearing out their brakes.  And I know this as I used to drive that way - getting 30K max out of a set of brake pads.  Today, I get 100K out of a set, without difficulty.  It's all in how you drive.

If  you see a red light or a stop sign ahead, let up on the gas and coast to a stop.  The less braking you do, the more money you save.  The inherent friction and air resistance will slow you down.  Bonus if the stop sign is up a hill - you can convert your momentum into a hill climb.  So few people do, though.

One more thing about hybrids.  There is a lot of FUD (Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt) being spread about hybrids and EVs.  I still hear from rednecks stories like, "Sure dem Priuses get good mileage, but after five years you have to replace the batteries and that costs ten grand!"  Car & Driver did a test where they compared a ten-year-old Prius to a brand-new one and found that the batteries had degraded, at most, by less than 5%.

These cars have been around a long time and are proving themselves to be not only as reliable as IC cars, but even moreso.  A Canadian friend of mine had her Prius stolen and the RCMP told her that it was likely put in a container and was on a ship to North Africa within hours of the theft.  Apparently the Toyota Prius has supplanted the Mercedes W123 (240D, 300D, etc.) as the car of choice for taxi drivers in the Arab world.  The Toyota Hilux pickup is similarly popular worldwide due to its durability.  I sold my 1988 4x4 to a guy who drove it to Guatemala and no doubt it is still tooling around there somewhere.

Having your Prius stolen is an odd endorsement of its quality, to be sure.  But it presence as a taxi (we saw a lot of them being used that way in Barcelona as well) is a sure sign that it is valued for its durability and reliability - FUD notwithstanding.

Thursday, May 30, 2024

For the Love Of Money.....

"For the love of money is the root of all evil." 1 Timothy 6:10

I was thinking the other night - a dangerous pastime - about how so many people in America worship the wealthy.  Whether it is Elon Musk fanboys or "Swifties" or people who follow sports stars or rap stars, it seems we all adore the wealthy and successful.  Well, maybe some do, I tend to be neutral about them.

Few people are fans of a local garage band or some obscure actor.  Few are fans of a sports player in the minor leagues or an unnoticed college athlete - I mean, other than their parents, of course.  It is only when they sign that multi-million-dollar contract that they become worthy of adulation and fandom.

And in some regard, some folks believe this is self-evident. If someone makes a lot of money, then they must have done something right or worked hard or was the best in their field.  I mean, if you won the lottery and became a billionaire, it wasn't just sheer luck - you were one of the chosen few!

Sounds stupid, but I think deep down, a lot of people think this way. Certainly billionaires do - about themselves.  But the reality is, extreme wealth is often a matter of luck.  Earning money - and more importantly, keeping it, requires real skill and hard work.  Many an athlete has signed contracts worth millions, only to be dead broke by age 40. Did they really deserve all those riches?  The folks who took the money away from them certainly didn't think so.

But it illustrates one way some folks get rich - by having fans or a following.  That seems to be the theme these days - everyone wants to be an "influencer" and have thousands of "followers."  Everyone wants to be a Main Character, but no one wants to be an ordinary person.  Problem is, not everyone can be a star.  There has to be an audience somewhere and at some time.

The quote from Timothy above is often truncated to "...[M]oney is the root of all evil!" much as 2nd Amendment types white-out the part about a well-regulated militia. No, the founding fathers didn't enact the Bill of Rights so you can go plink at old washing machines with your AR-15 on the weekends.  They had something more noble in mind.  And no, it was not insurrection.  But I digress.

The love of money is the problem, which I expounded on before.  Money itself is value-neutral - merely a tool to make an economy work in place of bartering.  But when money becomes an end in and of itself (and as a means of accumulating power) that's when it goes off the rails.

And yea, we can condemn those who hoard wealth and do evil things with it, to the detriment of a greater society.  But in most cases, it is we the citizens that allow them to accumulate wealth in the first place.  Most of these wealthy folks become wealthy not because they took our money away but because we willingly gave it to them.  Fan-boys and fan-girls hand over their life savings to go to a concert or buy the latest Apple phone or be seen in a Tesla.  And that is their choice, of course.  But you can't fly to Rio to catch the Swift concert and then text "wealth inequality sucks! - sent from my iPhone."

If we are ever to so something about wealth inequality, it begins with us.  And it begins with us not worshiping the wealthy like rock stars.  And that goes for the pretend-wealthy as well.  Marjorie Taylor Greene - the shame of Georgia - went on a Twitter rant about how Trump has contributed to society by building skyscrapers and "altering the New York City skyline" (like that hick knows anything about New York - I doubt she had ever left Georgia before she was elected!).  In other words, Trump is good because he was a successful "businessman" - although that balloon long ago popped as most if not all of his business ventures have failed and the only way he makes money is doing penny-ante things like grifting steaks and an online for-profit college.

But regardless, what I thought was interesting was that she admired Trump for his "success" - as false as it was.  In her mind, might makes right, and in this case, might is measured by dollar signs.  If you are wealthy, then you should be admired, followed, and listened to.  After all, you didn't just inherit that money and get lucky with it (or in Trump's case, squander it) - right?

Wealth-worship and worshiping the wealthy is, I believe, exactly what that quote from Timothy was getting at.  I am no Bible scholar, but reading the entire Chapter 6 of Timothy is interesting.  He (Paul) exhorts servants to serve their masters (no doubt added in translation somewhere along the way - can't have the Bible teaching Communism, can we?) provided, of course, that the master is a believer and does not blaspheme or confuse "gain" with godliness:

3 If any man teach otherwise, and consent not to wholesome words, even the words of our Lord Jesus Christ, and to the doctrine which is according to godliness;

4 He is proud, knowing nothing, but doting about questions and strifes of words, whereof cometh envy, strife, railings, evil surmisings,

5 Perverse disputings of men of corrupt minds, and destitute of the truth, supposing that gain is godliness: from such withdraw thyself.

Interesting.  Sounds like someone we all know - who confuses Gain with Godliness and holds his Bible upside-down, as only the Anti-Christ would do - right?

But such could be applied to anyone scrambling for wealth for wealth's sake.  Some men (and it is mostly men) try to accumulate vast sums of wealth in their lifetimes - far beyond what they need to support themselves in the foreseeable future (1 Timothy 6:19).  They still die, in the end, and their layabout children or grandchildren generally dissipate that wealth within a generation or two - or sometimes three.  It is inevitable, as each generation increases geometrically.  So what's the point?

There will always be such people, it is true.  Worshiping them, however, is to worship a false God.   Server your master (employer) if they are good people, "withdraw yourself" (quit) otherwise. But even if a rich person is a decent person who does good things, he is not worthy of worship - again a false God.

Worshiping wealth or the wealthy is just wrong.  And stupid.

Wednesday, May 29, 2024

The Problem Facing EVs

EVs are stuck in a bad place!

A reader sent me a link to a video (ugh!) about inventories of EVs.  Most dealers (and manufacturers) want to see 30 days or less of inventory in the pipeline - indicating that the vehicle is popular and that production is in line with sales.  But some EVs have six- to twelve-month backlogs on dealer lots.  Twelve months is problematic as it spans a model year and no one wants to pay new car prices for a year-old car.  At some point, you have to move the car over to the used car lot and sell it as a low-mileage used car.

What exactly is the problem? Well, it is Tesla, in part. Founders Martin Eberhard and Marc Tarpenning turned the EV business (such as it was) on its ear by creating a high-performance roadster (based on the Lotus Elise) that sold at luxury car prices.  Prior to that, EVs were touted as povertymobiles, built small and light as possible and hardly known for speed or agility.  The Tesla Roadster changed all that - offering supercar acceleration and handling - but at a steep price.

And it sold well.  The follow-on Model-S was sold not as some econobox for the environmentally conscious, but as a luxury car at luxury car prices.  Tesla sold all their production and had back-orders for years.  This didn't go unnoticed by other automakers.  EVs had largely failed in the marketplace as the products sold were tiny and tinny and punished their owners.  They were created - if at all - to meet possible government mandates, and not because the makers thought there was a real market for them. So the mindset was build cheap, sell cheap, and bank those carbon credits. It didn't work.

Tesla showed the way - that you can sell a $100,000+ electric car and make a huge profit and sell the carbon credits to other companies.  So everyone jumped in - again - but this time at the high end of the market.   As a result, we are flooded with a plethora of hundred-grand EVs and not enough people to buy them.

Yes, EVs are practical today - for a certain market demographic.  If you own your own home and can install a charging station, they work for you.  If not, well, a charging station better be nearby your apartment or at your place of work.  And you have to hope some jackass hasn't parked his monster truck, laden with Trump stickers, in front of the charging station to make some kind of stupid point. No, no, I think EVs, at the present time, are only practical if you own your own home.  But be prepared to spend some money running a 220V line and installing a charging station.  It ain't hard to do - for me, that is.  Others, who can't change a light bulb, have to hire someone.

But even for me, I am not sure it is practical - yet.  For one thing, I don't need or want a new car.  I don't want to spend the money when I am retired and living on my savings.   Sure, it would fit our "lifestyle" as a second car, but until our current car wears out, well, there really is no point.  I suspect a lot of people are in a similar situation.

And even if I was prepared to buy, well, $100,000 for a "luxury EV" is out of the question.  And the number of lower-priced options ($30,000) is very limited.  Oh, sure, in theory you might be able to buy a stripped Model-3 with limited range (and have to pay for all the software upgrades - no thanks!) but the reality is, once you option it up, it costs far more than that. Meanwhile, I can buy a "loaded" economy IC car, like our Hamster for far less.

GM offers a Hummer EV which isn't selling well.  Why?  Well, tying the defunct Hummer brand to an eco-conscious EV is just plain stupid marketing. The kind of ball-scratching beer-drinking demographic that loved the Hummer isn't going to be seen dead in an EV.  And at 9,000 lbs with battery packs, you aren't going offroad in one.  Off-roading and EVs don't mix really.  All that weight means they will get stuck.  Use a smaller battery pack to reduce weight and you get stuck when you run out of juice.  Either way, EVs aren't traversing Moab trails anytime soon.  They are well-suited to the highway, not the byway.

Ford offers an EV pickup, but again, the demographic for pickup buyers is really antagonistic to EVs.  While Ford has done a great job with that vehicle (and the Mache-E) no one is beating down the door to buy either.  For me, as an F-150 owner, again, I don't need to replace my vehicle right now.  We pretty much use our F150 to tow our camper (90% of mileage) and while formidable, even the extended-range F150 EV isn't going to go far dragging a 21-foot trailer down the road.  And that's considered a small trailer, too!

Not that it can't be done, but it limits one's options.  I met a Canadian man who was towing a 19-foot travel trailer (box type) with a Model-Y.  Even with the dual-motor extended range or whatever, he maxed out at 150 miles or less range, before having to stop.  He would either have to plan his trip so his lunch break coincided with a supercharger station, or jump from campground to campground, charging overnight. Already I am seeing signs at campgrounds forbidding EV charging.  That could become an issue.

My "Ecoboost" F150 cranks out 380 horsepower or thereabouts, out of a lightweight aluminum turbocharged engine and gets over 20 mpg when solo, and a decent (for RVing) 14 mpg when towing. With the extended-range 38-gallon tank, that means the vehicle has a potential range of over 700 miles driving solo, or over 500 when towing.  That's more than I ever want to drive in a day.  Clearly EVs are never going to entirely replace IC engine cars, unless there is another breakthrough in battery technology that doubles energy density - at the very least.

But that is not to say there is no market for EVs in America.  Roughly half (I estimate) of cars on the road are rarely driven more than 100 miles in a day, often far less.  And a huge number of Americans own their own homes in the suburbs (look out the window of an airplane sometime, we are a wealthy nation!).  Most people use their cars primarily to drive to work and back or go to the store.  Long trips are a once-a-year thing, if that.  So clearly, millions of people - over a hundred million, I suspect - could fit an EV into their lifestyle.

.If it was affordable.

Going after the high end of the market might have worked for Tesla, but that segment is saturated. And pickup trucks and huge SUVs don't seem like a natural fit for the EV market. Yet carmakers are pushing expensive EVs and not surprisingly, as the video linked above shows, those are the models lingering on dealer lots.  Affordable EVs still seem to be selling fairly well.  But again, these are not smart-phones.  People aren't throwing away their old cars to jump on the EV bandwagon - they will wait until their old car is ready for a trade.  So sales will be a trickle, not a flood.

Of course, there are exceptions.  The Elon fan-boys, like Apple fan-boys, are jumping at the chance to have tha latest-and-greatest - a "Cybertruck" - and realizing after taking delivery that it is a very expensive, heavy, and large vehicle ill-suited for real truck activities.  And they now realize that they signed a contract agreeing not to sell their cybertruck for a certain period of time, lest the secondary market get flooded (bad pun, sorry) with used cybertrucks.

Meanwhile, Tesla is aggressively slashing prices of its long-in-the-tooth legacy products, which is again causing regret for owners who bought last year and now see their resale prices plummet as new car prices drop.  Many are upside-down on their loans as the balance due is more than the cost of a new Tesla.  And what will happen when hundreds of thousands of leases end and the projected "residual" is nowhere near the actual resale value?   Yea, that.  Now you know why Elon is milking Tesla dry before it goes the way of Kaiser-Frazer or Studebaker.

A price war on EVs could be good business for consumers - and may, ironically, jump-start sales.  When prices go low enough, some folks (even myself!) might jump in.  And once you have an EV and your own charging station, you might be inclined to buy another one, down the road.  Then again, EVs have the potential to last decades, if properly maintained.

I met a fellow over the holiday who thinks he had more money that he does. "I'll just work until I'm 70!" he says.  Translation: I am dead broke and up to my eyeballs in debt buying things I don't really need so I can't quit my job if I wanted to.  He serially leases cars - Cadillacs - every two years.  The salesman called him up and offered him a "deal" on a new EV Caddy as they are not selling very well.  He says he will likely take the deal - a short-term lease.  I wonder if, two years from now, if he will go back to IC engines or be an EV convert.

Cadillac sells EVs, but GM's lesser brands, that used to sell EVs, no longer do - although a Chevy EV SUV is allegedly coming out this year and there is talk of bringing back the Chevy Bolt - again.

In a way, perhaps there is an historical precedence for this.  GM used to introduce new technologies in its more expensive brands, before they trickled down to lesser marques.  One exception was the automatic transmission, which debuted with Oldsmobile (Dynaflow notwithstanding) before it was adopted by Cadillac.  The thinking was, if it turned out to be a dud, it would not tarnish the Cadillac marque. Sadly, other technologies didn't follow suit and things like the V8-6-4 gave Cadillac a black eye in later years.

More expensive cars can absorb the research and development costs of technology more easily - and pay back the investment more quickly. Higher-priced car buyers are more likely to pay extra for "features" as they are a form of status.  But eventually, these features trickle down to even the most plebeian of vehicles.  Hard to believe today, but air conditioning, automatic transmissions, power windows, power door locks, cruise control, power steering, and power brakes were once only options and only available on upscale brands.  And often, they didn't work well, either!  Today, it is hard to find even an econo-box without all of these features, standard.  Back in 1938, a "fully loaded" Chevy meant you had a radio and heater.  Not kidding!

So in a way, it made more sense for EVs to start at the top of the market and trickle down - as Tesla aptly demonstrated.  By the time other automakers got into the game, however, the technology should have been available at lower price points.  Luxury car buyers are also less interested in $7500 tax rebates on hundred-thousand-dollar cars.  And "saving money on gas" doesn't even register with such folks.

It is time for EVs to move downmarket.

Thursday, May 23, 2024

Stupidity and Totalitarianism

Fascists are stupid and cruel - and that is why they are doomed to eventual failure.

I read this comment on Reddit, which was made in response to another comment that fascists are basically dumb and cruel.  I wish I had the link.  I copied the text and when I went back later to find the source it was *poof* gone.  Anyway, I thought this was an interesting analysis:
This right here is something I think more folks should keep in mind.

I think a lot of folks in countries that haven't been exposed directly to real destruction mostly understand dictators from fiction (either fictional villains or highly dramaticized/fictionalized accounts of real dictators), and fiction has a tendency to give way too much credit to the intelligence of evil dictators.

Like, the Nazis in popular portrayal were evil, but were also [portrayed as] ruthlessly efficient and organized and competent...but that was not the case. The Nazis were hilariously corrupt (Hitler was secretly paying bribes to tons of people from the public treasury to buy their loyalty) and cripplingly stupid (they refused to engage with entire branches of science for ideological reasons and wasted countless resources on the most ridiculous weapons and pet projects because Hitler came up with them).

They weren't just horrible because they were evil towards certain people...they were horrible because they were evil and incredibly wasteful and incompetent and left even the people they supposedly liked worse off. There was absolutely no upside to them. They did a bunch of cruel and horrible things for stupid and moronic reasons...and just left the world worse in every way.

And this is crucial as we head into a world where these sorts of dictatorial movements are becoming more popular. A lot of people kind of get off on being aligned with the "bad guys", because they imagine that they will become part of this coldly ruthless organization that, while it is brutal to enemies, it will ultimately make society more orderly and efficiently or whatever, and they fancy themselves as "stronger" because they're willing to make the hard choice to sacrifice others for the greater good.

But in reality, dictators are pretty much entirely idiots at everything except hanging onto power. And they end up making society way less orderly, efficient, or pleasant for anyone.

The very structure of a dictatorship means that the people who question or challenge the dictator end up dead, so there isn't anybody to stop the dictator from ordering all kinds of stupid and even impossible things. And a lot of dictators get into power because they're willing to make stupid choices that ultimately make everything worse and that most people wouldn't choose because it's counter productive. They are willing to destroy their own home to rule it.

Dictators generally aren't "evil geniuses" -- that is a concept people seem fascinated with and thus is popular in fiction, but like many things in fiction it doesn't generally happen in reality. Dictators are evil idiots who kill everyone who tries to correct them and over time surround themselves with murderous yes men who will hollow out their society until it either collapses or gets taken over by someone else, and they invariably leave societies poorer and more miserable than they were in the first place.

And the sooner people stop seeing this sort of idiocy as "strength", the better.

I thought this was an interesting take, as a lot of people think Mussolini "made the trains run on time!"  But in fact, he didn't.  In fact, other than win small wars against basically unarmed opposition, he didn't do much except turn Italy into ruin.

People claim dictators improved the economy - in an era where economies were recovering from great recessions and even a depression.  "Hitler built the Autobahns and put Germans back to work!" they say.  But highways would have been built with or without Hitler and none of it was his vision or idea. In fact, the idea originated in the predecessor (and Democratic) Weimar Republic.

You go down the list and you see the same pattern again and again.  Stalin's amateur efforts at industrialization and collectivism produced low-quality goods and starved millions of peasants. Mao followed suit, killing even more.  The Khmer Rouge slaughtered nearly 1/3 of the population because one man had a crazy idea about emptying cities and sending everyone to the country to farm.

In fact, there is no track record of a dictator making things better or making wise decisions.  The "wise old king" of fairy tales simply doesn't exist.  When you have absolute power and everyone lives in fear of you, no one is there to say "uh, that sounds like a really bad idea!"

The only thing consistent across various dictatorships is the cruelty, the slaughter, the suffering, and the secret police.  But even that is inefficient, as innocents are tortured and killed while insurgencies still manage to flourish.  The "pick me!" people who think they will be on the good side of the dictator and reap huge rewards are often the first put before the firing squad, as they are viewed as potential rivals or conspirators.

Just look at all the people Trump has thrown under the bus - once his loyal acolytes, and now, yesterday's news.

Corruption is the other constant with dictatorships.  We see this today in Russia, where oligarchs loot the system and we discover that Russia has basically a cardboard army.  Where did all the money go, that was supposed to re-arm Russia?  Into the hands of the oligarchs.

We have an election this year, and one candidate - Trump - promises to make himself dictator-for-life and eliminate his enemies.  And a substantial number of people think this is a swell idea, too.  Sadly for them, again, it is likely they will be the first put before the firing squad, or sent out as cannon fodder, or told to work long hours for low wages, or see their homes and livelihood destroyed. Likely all of the above.

The track record of dictators is consistently dismal - there are no "good" dictators in history.  Not a single one.

So why do people pine for authoritarianism?  Well, they are stupid, to be sure.  They believe that complex problems can be solved with simple solutions.  Worldwide migration due to war, famine, and economic hardship?  Build a wall!  That'll keep 'em out!  It didn't work for China or Hadrian, it isn't working on our Southern border, either.  Complex problems require complex solutions - but you lose the average stupid voter once you try to explain things.  Simple slogans, chanted endlessly (a favorite of the far-left, by the way - another contingent of the stupid voter) are far easier to get across to the dumb.

This, of course, is assuming the "problems" are real and not hyped or imagined.  Postwar Germany after WWI was in economic free-fall and the punishing terms of the Versailles treaty didn't help matters any.  But oddly enough, the Nazis rose to power during a period when the economy was slowly recovering.  People were tired of recession, and the Nazis amplified each economic hardship to make them seem worse than they were.  They engaged in street violence and then promised to put a stop to it - if put into power.

And of course, they had scapegoats - the other consistent aspect of dictators.  Nearly every Latin American or Middle-East dictator burns an effigy of Uncle Sam and tells their followers that the mean old USA is the reason their economy is in tatters.  Castro - and his successors - blame the US embargo for the failure of Communism in their country.  Yet, there is no embargo with Canada, Europe, or most of the rest of the world.  So why does an embargo with one country wreck their economy?  The short answer is, it hasn't, communism has.  But one way to stay in power is to blame your failures on a scapegoat.

It could be another country or a race or a religion or whatever.  Today in America, the far-right is blaming all the country's woes (such as they are, with the economy booming and America really the only remaining super-power) on anyone who isn't white, Christian, and heterosexual.  We are told that we need to "take back" our country from those icky "race" people and go back to the good old days of polio and racism.

You go first.

The reality is, of course, that things are hardly as bad as either the far-left or far-right make it out to be.  Certainly whatever "problems" we have in this country can be solved without having to destroy our Democracy.

But then again, it seems every few decades, we forget the lessons of the past and people - stupid people - start to think, "Say, maybe Communism or Nazism wasn't such a bad idea after all!"

Like I said, they are stupid people.