Monday, May 3, 2010

Intentionally Making Less Money

Everyone wants to make more money, right?
Suppose you could have more by making less?


One of the interesting aspects of working for a living is that at a certain point, you end up making less and less money, the harder you work.  Our tax system is structured largely to increase your tax burden as you make more and more money.   Rates go up as your income increases.

But lest you feel too sorry for the rich, bear in mind that the 50% and 75% brackets of the past are now history.  The highest rates today are around 38%. And bear in mind that once you make over $100,000 a year or so, your Social Security and Medicare deductions drop to zilch - effectively LOWERING your tax rate.

And bear in mind too, that once you are making $250,000 or more a year, a lot of tax shelters start to be cost-effective.  Buying investment Real Estate is one of them - and a neat way to convert ordinary income in to capital gains.

But we know how that Real Estate thing worked out, don't we?

The problem for many of these near-rich is that in addition to taxes, their lives become exponentially more expensive as they make more money.  Your typical Doctor or Lawyer, as his career starts to take off, buys more and more expensive cars, usually leasing them to "avoid the hassle" of buying and selling. They move into a tacky mini-mansion in the suburbs with staggering mortgage payments, tax bills, and insurance.  And likely, they are "upside-down" on that mini-mansion as we speak.

And then there are other expensive luxuries, such as divorce and re-marriage - essentially supporting two families on the income of one.

And of course, you don't become a successful doctor or lawyer these days by working 40 hours a week. Chances are, you are at the office 60 hours or more.   So you hire a maid to clean your house, a gardener to do your lawn, and even someone to walk your dog (I kid you not, I know lawyers who do this).

And you shop and Whole Foods, because that's where people of your caliber shop, right?  And you buy expensive clothes and eat out 4 or 5 nights a week, possibly due to business.

The net result, for many high-earners is that while the have a lavish lifestyle, they are really no wealthier than the plumber down the street who makes half as much, works half as many hours, but puts more into savings and spends less.

So no wonder these "High Earners" are upset about the economy.  They spend all day chasing their tails, trying to earn more and more, only to see it flow through their hands that much quicker.  You might as well try shoveling water.

I started to fall into this trap myself.   My career as a Patent Attorney was doing well and I was making well into the six figures with promise of much more.   But I was not really creating real wealth, even through I was working long hours.  The amount of money I was putting away was not nearly enough, and my debt load kept increasing.

And the only way out of this mess seemed to me to be to earn yet more money, which would have meant yet more hours at the office, becoming estranged from my spouse, and eventually ending up in a bitter break-up.  You see, to get that incremental extra dollar, in any line of work, often means working much harder than you did for that first dollar. You want to double your income?   Better work three times as hard!

Then one day, I decided that there had to be another way to live.  Could I work half as hard, perhaps, and earn three-quarters as much money - but spend even less?  By cutting spending and living frugally, could I sock away MORE money, enjoy life more, and have more real wealth?

Well, I started this experiment about five years ago.  And so far, it seems to be working.   It has taken a lot of re-thinking of everything I do, from my business model to even the most trivial expense (or what seemed to be a trivial expense!).

When I was a "big-shot" with the corner office in the office park, I would have laughed if you had told me that perhaps spending $20-$50 on lunch was excessive and foolish.  Hey, I'm making good money, right? I can afford it!

But cumulatively, these "I'm making good money I can afford it!" decisions add up to an expensive lifestyle that sucks the life out of your income and leaves you feeling broke and frustrated.  After all, you are making the six-figure income, you should feel wealthy, right?   But you aren't.

The secret is really simple: Learn to live like someone earning half to three-quarters what you are presently making.  Impossible, you say?  Well, tell that to the legion of people in this country who get by one half to three-quarters of what you make.  They'd be surprised to hear that.

Once you can do that, you can use the excess income to pay down debt, invest in your 401(k) and create real wealth.  Within a few years, you'll find that you have enough money in the bank to not have to work at all.

And when you can do that - that is REAL wealth.  Not having to labor to pay the bills or dance to someone else's tune.

Because, let's face it - no matter how much money you make, so long as you are beholden to a boss, a partnership, a client, or whatever, you are not really wealthy and never will be.

True wealth is being financially independent.

Why I sold my Tractor...

My Tractor is for sale on eBay and will be gone in about 7 days

I am selling my antique tractor on eBay and the wonderful thing about eBay is that in about 7 days, whatever you put on there is sold, no bones about it, if it is priced attractively. If not, lower the price and re-list it for another 7 days. It will sell, eventually.

Why sell it? Well, for starters, we decided to get off the Great American Lawn merry-go-round and let our five-acre field go back to being a field. The cost savings in fuel alone will be well over $100 a year, perhaps double that. And the time saved will be dozens of hours.

So the reason I bought the tractor no longer exists. I bought it to mow the lawn and we no longer are mowing the lawn. When you own a piece of equipment and no longer use it, sell it, before it degrades from lack of use. And sell it, when it is in prime condition and you can get the most money for it.

Now some folks have told me, "Gee you can't sell your tractor, that's a classic!" Well, that sort of thinking leads people to hang onto things longer than they should. Defining yourself by what you own is never a very smart idea. If you think of yourself as "Mr. Harley" or "Mr. BMW" or "Mr. Bayliner" or "Mr. Jeep" or "Mr. Tractor" it is, to begin with, a very shallow existence. Owning a piece of equipment is fun, for about 15 minutes. Using it may be fun for a few years. But one should never let any piece of machinery own them.

You hear this all the time in car and motorcycle forums. "I'll never sell my Harley" a 30-something says, "Live to Ride, Ride to Live!" they cry. But like anything else done repetitively over the years, it eventually loses its allure. And you see old Harleys languishing in a barn or garage, because the owner can't bear to part with them.

And I am not picking on Harleys - fill in the blank with any other consumer good you want to name. People think these things will last forever (they don't) that they are worth a lot of money (they aren't) and that they are worth hanging onto.

I recently saw this in a BMW forum. A young fellow was convinced his decade-old BMW was a "collectible classic". Maybe in 30 years it will be. But today it is just another used car, depreciating annually. He will sell it, eventually, not to a collector, but to some chump who will drive the wheels off it and junk it. Most cars end up this way, even "collectible classics". And that's why the old collectible classics are worth a lot of money - because so few of them survived.

And as I have noted time and time again, it is never a worthwhile financial proposition to try to keep a new car until it is collectible. In your lifetime, a car will not likely appreciate in value enough to pay back the purchase price. And the cost of ownership over the years will insure that it will be a negative investment.

Classic cars are worth tons of money mostly because it took tons of money to restore them to the Concours condition that commands high prices. No one is going to pay collector prices for your daily ride or a 15-year old used car.

Collector cars are rarely driven, but are more talismans than actual cars. So in order to be collectible a car, tractor, Harley, or whatever has to be never driven (a survivor) or restored to pristine condition and then rarely used.

For most of us, this is not the case - we merely own used cars, bikes, or whatever.

So forget about the idea of "saving" a piece of machinery as an investment, because as investments go, it is rarely a good one.

And while we may think of our particular vehicle as "rare" and collectible, chances are, it really isn't. Many items that are rare are still not collectible, if there is not a demand for them. For example, these Ford tractors are fun to own, but they are not very expensive to buy. Ford made a lot of them, and a lot of them survived. They basically never wear out, so you can find them all day long in sheds and barns. Parts are cheap and they are easy to restore. So prices for these tractors, even after 70 years (!!!!) languish in the $3000 to $5000 range. Even a "pristine" restoration would be lucky to break the $10,000 barrier. There are just too many of them out there to make them expensive.

BMWs suffer from the same problem. Like any mass-produced car, there are just too many out there. Even the iconic 2002 might be lucky to break $10,000 on a good day, for a well-restored example. The problem is, while we all might have fond memories of such cars, the reality of them is something else. Time has marched on, and these tiny, buzzy cars are not exactly safety machines. A pristine restoration cannot be driven. Anything less than a pristine restoration is a PITA to drive. Newer cars are better and better made, so most people opt for newer iron. While it is fun to LOOK at an older car, most of us really don't want to own one, from a practical perspective.

So the idea of hanging onto a piece of machinery as an "investment" is foolish. Use it for its intended purpose, maintain it, enjoy it, and when the time comes you are no longer using it, sell it and use the money for some other purpose.

When should you take a LOSS?

Owning GM stock was quite a sleigh ride.
Today the stock is nearly worthless.

It is disappointing when one of your investments does this. When you should you call it a day and sell?

As I noted in my Realization Events posting, you don't actually "experience" a loss, from a tax perspective, until a realization event occurs- you buy or sell the stock. So if you keep a loss "on the books" so to speak, you haven't really experienced any real loss.

But when you actually sell the tanked stock, you experience a realization event, and thus "realize" your loss and can thus take it as a deduction from your income for tax purposes.

So should you do this? Well, like anything else, "it depends".

To begin with, unless you are past the age of 59-1/2, you can't really realize losses from your IRA, 401(k), SEP or other pre-tax retirement accounts. And even then, they are just losses, not realized losses from a tax perspective, as we shall see later.

For example, I rolled over one of my 401(k) accounts into a self-directed IRA with eTRADE. Is this a good idea? Well, the account is worth about what I put into it about two years ago. During the "big crash" my self-directed picks dropped about 15% in value, compared to 25-30% for my Fidelity account. So I have done OK with it.

But as we shall see, one problem with stocks is that they can drop in value all the way to ZERO, which means, if you self-direct your IRA, you could ride it all the way down to nothing. Paying off your mortgage, on the other hand, is a far less riskier proposition.

Using my eTRADE account as an example, I have picked three real loser stocks over the years - ones that have tanked to zero or near-zero: General Motors, Fleetwood Enterprises (the largest maker of RVs) and Fannie Mae. In each case, we are tallking about "investments" of only a couple of thousand dollars. The great thing about low-cost brokerages, is that you can diversify your investment for only a few dollars a trade.

Taking my GM investment as an example, I paid $35.69 a share for 50 shares of the stock, or about $1830. Obviously this is not enough of a risk to bankrupt me. But nevertheless, it is an example of poor investing. I did not do enough research or think about why I was buying the stock, other than it seemed to be doing well at the time and, hey, it's General Motors we're talking about, what could go wrong? It's not like the world's largest car company will go bankrupt, right?

Well, we all know how that worked out. I now am the proud owner of 50 shares of something called "Motors Liquidation Company" stock, worth about 65 cents a share, or $32.70 in total, a loss of $1763.79 and a decline in value of 98.18%

I can be flippant about this loss, as I have diversified my portfolio. I try not to put all my eggs in one basket. Anyone foolish enough to put all their money in GM stock would be broke right now, like those poor saps who put their entire 401(k) in ENRON stock. Never, ever, invest all in one thing!

But getting back to realization events, if this were a after-tax trading account (such as my AmeriTrade account) I could sell my Motors Liquidation stock and take a $1763.79 loss, which would equate to about a $650 cut in my income taxes, if I was in the top bracket. There is little point in hanging onto the stock - Motors Liquidation Corp is unlikely to ever bounce back to $35 a share anytime soon.

So every December, before the end of the tax year, it pays to look through your portfolio and see if you have one of these stinkers in your after-tax investments. If you do, well, then you should think about selling it and taking the loss - and cutting your tax liability in the process.

But what about losses in your 401(k)? Well, there's the rub, and one reason I may end up a shareholder in "Motors Liquidation" for a long, long time. You see, there is no tax write-off on monies you never paid taxes on in the first place. Since the money in this self-directed IRA has never been taxed, I can't claim a corresponding deduction on my taxes.

In this case, it is a loss that is offset by other gains, with no realization event from a tax perspective. Even when I reach age 59-1/2 and can draw from my IRA, I won't be able to claim the "loss" to my income, as I never paid taxes on the money in the first place. The only effect the loss will have is by decreasing the balance on my IRA, it means I have less money to take out of the plan, and thus will pay less taxes as a result. The net result is the same.

Now again, if this were in my after-tax account (which I maintain with AmeriTrade) I could take the loss on December 31, and have a nice deduction for my taxes. But that does not mean you should only invest in stocks with after-tax money. It merely illustrates the different mechanics involved.

Chances are, your 401(k) or IRA is invested with stocks, just in the form of mutual funds. When an individual stock tanks in your mutual fund, you do not declare a loss, it only affects the overall mutual fund price. And when you retire, you will pay taxes on the amounts you withdraw from the fund - which is all taxable, as the money in the fund was never taxed. An individual "loss" on money in the fund means only that you might have less money to pay taxes on.

But the self-directed 401(k) plan does have one anomaly. My eTRADE account charges $9.99 per trade to buy or sell stocks. Sometimes they have 2- or 3-for-1 "specials" or even free trade days, but for the most part, I have to pay a fee, albeit a small one, to sell any stock. Motors Liquidation is now worth $32.50 in my account. Is it worth paying $9.99 to sell the stock when there is no realization event that occurs?

Or how about my Fleetwood stock, now worth a staggering twenty-eight cents - not per share, the whole darn investment! Is it worth spending nearly ten bucks just to take this off the books?

Of course not. So these stinkers stay in my eTRADE account, as painful reminders of bad choices I have made in the past. In a way, they are sobering, and perhaps worthwhile to keep in there. For every AVIS stock pick I made (1200% gain in 8 months, nearly $10,000 in gain!) I have at least one GM or Fleetwood or Fannie Mae.

Investing in stocks, for the average Joe, is like buying a pig in a poke. There is little transparency in the market. Prospectuses and Annual Reports are indecipherable to the average investor. Most of us rely on the rationalization of the market to inform us of values, and that is perhaps the worst mistake we can make.

If a million people think GM stock is worth $35 a share, then that must be a pretty good evaluation of its market value, right? Well, as we have discovered, that isn't always the case. Markets can be irrational, and even seasoned investors, professionals, and Wall Street Gurus can be very, very wrong on the evaluation of stocks and other investments. In the case of GM, it might be market trends that people couldn't see or refused to see. In the case of ENRON, it might be outright fraud.

In either case, the small investor has little or no way of knowing how an investment will do in the future. Will the market for widgets dry up in a year or two? Or are the officers of the company looting the place, rigging the books and then leaving by the emergency exit and pulling the ripcords on their golden parachutes? For us, it is hard to tell.

Diversifying your investment portfolio is one way to protect yourself from an overwhelming loss. Research and investigation is another. Never rely on market price or market price charts as a guide to the underlying value of an investment. As many of the "Gold Bugs" will no doubt soon discover, just because something is going up, up, up, doesn't mean it will go that way forever.

But hey, on the plus side, they'll have a staggering loss to take on their taxes!

Saturday, May 1, 2010

Patio Furniture


Patio Furniture used to be staggeringly expensive.
While cheap today, it can still be costly, in terms of ownership.
Upholstered pieces like this, with painted aluminum frames, might not last very long.

When I was a kid, patio furniture was staggeringly expensive. Everything was back then, but most young people today don't realize it. For example, a Coleman steel-belted cooler was like $99 back in the 1960's. My Dad, who was pretty well off, could never afford one. Bear in mind that a car was only $2500 then, and you realize how staggeringly expensive $99 was. You could buy a TV for that much.

Fast forward 40 years and the Coleman steel-belted cooler is still $99. And similar items that were staggeringly expensive back then - Webber kettles and the like - are now the same price, but inflation has made them affordable for everyone. We truly are lucky today.

Heck, back then, you might own two of those flimsy aluminum folding outdoor chairs, the kind with the interwoven webbing - remember those? Or perhaps you had the matching loungers. And when the webbing went south, you re-webbed them with a kit from the store. Today, such chairs are still sold, but are disposed of within a season or two. Young people today give you a blank stare when you mention re-webbing kits.

Back in the 1960's, you bought real patio furniture at a patio furniture store. The local "lumber yard" did not carry it, and places like Lowes, Home Depot, and the like didn't exist. And when you went to those stores, the furniture was priced like home furniture - very, very dear.

Today, you can go to Lowes, Home Depot, Wal-Mart, and even Target, and see attractive patio furniture sets for only a few hundred dollars. Are these a good deal? Well, perhaps compared to the prices of the past. The problem is, many of these sets last only a season or two, so far from being a major investment purchase, they really are a disposable consumer item.

Many sets today are made of aluminum, heli-arc welded together and given a very attractive spray coating that mimics hammered metal, verdigris bronze, or whatever. They look great in the show room. Many have plastic webbing and "water resistant" cushions. Others have mesh fabrics stretched between frames.

The problem with these types of chairs is that after one or two seasons, they look poorly and often are ready for the trash. Unless kept under cover (porch or screened room) the sun fades the unique finish so that it no longer looks like hammered metal, but some weird white-powdered faded photo of metal. Cushions rot and mildew (so much for water resistance) and fabric and strap sag and break. The aluminum oxidizes and bubbles up the painted finish.

So yes, these types of patio sets are super-cheap, but they don't last more than a few years. So like cheap household furniture, you get what you pay for.

I have found that sturdier wrought-iron furniture, purchased used, can be a much better bargain. When I say "wrought iron" what I mean is welded steel. Actual forged steel is rarely used today. Cast metal pieces (often very uncomfortable) are more often made of aluminum and that is not what I am talking about.

A "wrought iron" patio furniture set like this
can last for decades with little or no maintenance,
other than an occasional can of spray paint.

I saw a "for sale" ad once at the Safeway, advertising a set of "rod iron" furniture. While I laughed at this redneck gaffe, in retrospect, the advertiser was not far off the mark, as most of this furniture is made of metal wire stock welded together, using expanded metal for seat backs and bases.

Why do I think this type of furniture is a good deal? Well, for starters, it basically lasts forever. Unless you let it really, really rust, it will give decades of good service.

Second, it can be had for cheap, used. Like our Safeway example above, or on Craig's list, you can find this stuff anywhere. And it is all basically the same style, so it matches what you have. We recently bought two chairs and and end table for $25, in perfect condition. Last year, we bought a 48" round dining table and four chairs for $40, and turned around and sold the table for $40, keeping the chairs for free. Free is a price I really like!

Third, there are no cushions to deal with. These chairs are comfortable without cushions. If need be, you can find generic thin cushions (as opposed to those comfortable looking but actually uncomfortable thick cushions in the fancy aluminum-framed sets) to put on them. But the main thing is, most patio furniture, once the cushions are shot, is junk, as you can't buy replacement cushions for them (they make sure of that by changing sizes slightly). With wrought iron chairs, no cushions are needed, so there is no built-in obsolescence.

Fourth, there is little maintenance to these chairs. Hose them off occasionally, or just let the rain do its thing. They may require painting occasionally, but a simple spray can is all you need there.

Fifth, you can paint them in colors. We use a Rustoleum metallic blue on ours, making all the parts of the sets matching. They look unique, and everyone comments "where did you get these cool chairs?" Craigslist and a can of Rustoleum. It's our secret, OK?

Sixth, when you go to sell these chairs, you'll likely get back all your money. Unlike the aluminum chairs with cushions that all go to the curb eventually, these wrought iron chairs last forever, and when you move or no longer need them, chances are, you can sell them for what you paid for them back then.

The patio sets sold in the big-box stores look appealing, but they are very pricey, considering how long they last. Beautiful displays, with tents, patio furniture, even outdoor rugs, can tempt the consumer to whip out a credit card and buy, thinking that he is making a lifetime purchase. But within a few years, that type of furniture looks pretty ratty. The outdoor tent has blown over, or the fabric has faded and torn. The cushions have faded and mildewed and are torn. Straps are hanging down and stretched fabric has bowed. Repair is just not a cost-effective option, even if you could find the materials to repair such chairs.

But "rod iron" patio chairs, bought used for cheap, will last year and years - perhaps a lifetime. Occasional touch-up with a spray can is all that is needed to keep them in top shape. Cheaper to buy, cheaper to own, lasts longer, and holds its value. It really is a no-brainer, isn't it?

UPDATED April 9, 2017 to reformat and replace "wrought iron" image.  Oddly enough, the original URL I linked to is now dead, but other sites have copied the image from this page and now I can link to those.   The Internet is weird.

UPDATED 2021 to refresh the images.  We saw a lady at the Goodwill the other day loading a wrought iron patio set like this into the back of her luxury SUV. The stuff was covered with pollen and dirt, but was otherwise serviceable. A little hosing off and some spray can and she's got a patio set for the rest of her life.

Should you buy a Vacation Home?

Are You Ready to Buy a Vacation Home? 6 Questions to Ask First ...
A vacation home is a wonderful luxury. But should you own one, or just rent it?

You are sitting on the beach in a tropical paradise. Amadore, your waiter, brings you one tropical drink after another. The sound of the surf lulls you to sleep in your hammock. You have the beginnings of a great tan. And you've had day after day of great vacation sex.

Wonderful vacation. Want to ruin it entirely? Pick up the local paper.

There are two ways to ruin a perfectly good vacation. One is to read the local paper and read all about the insane local politics and the local idiots. Believe it or not, in any vacation destination area, the locals are all loco. You'd think they'd be happy living in paradise, but they are not. In fact, they generally are more malcontent than normal people. Talk to them and they will dredge up a list of grievances against the local government, the mayor, their neighbors, the developers, the department of environmental conservation, the tourists, the hotels, the cruise ships, whatever. They simply have nothing else to do but complain about how bad they have it. Chances are, they never even go to the beach anymore, or enjoy the amenities of the resort area. Do you want to end up like that?

So do yourself a favor, stay out of the local politics, and if a "local" (defined as some tourist like you who moved there 6 months ago) tries to engage you in conversation, quickly back away.

The second way to ruin a perfectly good vacation is to look at buying real estate there. It is a very typical reaction. After all, you are having such a good time, enjoying yourself. Why not own a "slice of paradise" as the local real estate agent's sign says?

To begin with, you will basically ruin the rest of your vacation. No more mimosas on the beach, but instead trudging from one open house to another, spending time in stuffy real estate agent's offices, and scrounging listings in the paper. So much for good vacation sex, too. Just as you get the wife in the mood, she'll start thinking about granite counter tops.

The first thing that will aggravate you about buying vacation real estate is the pricing. Even if demand is slack, the locals put crazy prices on things, convinced that interest in property equals demand, and that "rich tourists" are stupid and will pay insane prices without thinking. And since many people fall for this scam, the prices become self-fulfilling. So thousands of people end up paying more to own a vacation condo that it would ever cost to rent it, and they really don't understand why.

What are the pros of buying vacation Real Estate? Well they sound like a lot at first, but when you take the cons into account, they more than cancel out.
1. You always have a place to go on vacation: This is true, but now that you have two mortgages to pay, you rarely have time off from work to go there. You'll end up "house poor" times two. If you are like most "salary slaves" out there, chances are you'll get only two weeks a year, tops to enjoy your vacation home. 
2. You can rent it out and make money, which helps defray costs: This is also true, but guess what? The peak times for rentals are also when you want to use the property. So if you want to use the property on labor day weekend, go ahead. But you've just killed your most profitable rental week. Using the property "off season" is one solution, but hey, what's the point of that? 
Also, no matter how you do the math, the costs of real estate agent's fees, damage to the property, cleaning costs, etc. cut into the rental income. And even if you can rent for nearly every week of the year, the overhead costs still end up higher than what you would pay to rent the same house for the few days a year you get to use it. 
In other words, you pay for the privilege of owning a place - more than you would to rent the same place. The renters are the smart ones, the owners are the fools. 
3. The home may appreciate in value as an investment: This can also be true, or as we learned recently, entirely false. A beautiful vacation home on the outer banks with a view of the ocean might appreciate in value, unless the market crashes as it recently did. Or if a developer puts 500 homes on the property next door, depressing prices. Or worse yet, if someone builds on that "unbuildable lot" in front of you and destroys your view.
Housing prices can go up - and they can go down. In the case of vacation homes, way down. When the recession hit, the first thing people unloaded were luxuries - vacation homes, RVs, boats, motorcycles - things they did not "need" and were a major drain on cash flow. And vacation condos are even worse. They can soar in price and crash just as hard. 
For beach properties, throw in hurricanes, floods, and storms, which periodically batter such areas. Yes, you have insurance (usually three policies, fire, wind, and flood, costing thousands of dollars a year). But after a major storm, prices drop.
And even if prices go up, up, up, expect another pleasant surprise: The tax man will nail you with an increased assessment. Suddenly, your $2000 a year tax bill is $5000 a year. And as an out-of-State owner, you don't qualify for the homestead exemption the locals get. 
4. You can buy the home now, rent it out, and have it paid for as a retirement home when you retire: This is another option, and several friends of mine have done this. Does it work? Well, sort of. Again, you have a negative cash flow for many, many years, as the rental costs don't keep up with the mortgage, taxes, insurance, repairs, agency fees, maintenance, etc. And when it is time to retire, chances are, you'll have to gut the house and remodel it, as after 15-20 years of renters, the place is probably ready for a new everything.
Now, in some instances, this scheme might work. For example, you buy a place for cheap and hang onto it for many, many years. But in other scenarios, if you pay too much, well, you could end up having squandered tens of thousands of dollars over the years for nothing. 
You have to do the math to find out which is the best alternative. In some instances, it may simply be better to take all that negative cash flow money and put it in the bank, or use it to pay down your existing mortgage. When you are ready to retire, you can just go and buy the retirement home you want - where you want - and not be locked into some decision you made 15 years ago. The isolated beach house you bought in 1995 might be a crowded, noisy, spring break community in 2015. 
5. You get a tax deduction on interest paid on vacation home mortgages: Again, this is true, but again, don't confuse a deduction with wealth. You cannot deduct your way to wealth, just as you cannot eat your way to slimness. The tax deduction is just another factor in your "do the math" part of the problem. And unfortunately, government incentives like this often do not pan out to real advantage. Rather, the market adjusts by increasing prices to offset the benefit of the deduction. 
While it is a good idea to take advantage of deductions when they are offered, altering your finances to get a deduction, when it provides no advantage or financially stresses you, makes no sense whatsoever. 
As I noted before, there is a tax credit for buying an electric car. Buying an electric car and parking it on your front lawn makes no sense. It does not make you wealthier or save you money. On the other hand, if you plan on buying an electric car because you want one, the tax credit is something to take into consideration. And guess what? The electric car people know about the tax credit and have adjusted their prices accordingly. Funny how that works. 
You should live your life the way you want to live it, and not look at the tax code as some sort of Bible for proper living. And in this regard, perhaps the "teabaggers" have some sort of point. Offering deductions, credits, and incentives for certain behaviors is a way the government has of manipulating people's behavior, and one wonders whether the government should be in that business. 
And in effect, it ends up subsidizing one person's behavior by another's. The person who doesn't install new energy-efficient replacement windows ends up, in effect, subsidizing the replacement cost of the neighbor who does. We have to wonder whether these tax incentives are really all that fair. 
But taking politics aside, you have to crunch the numbers. And tax deduction or not, oftentimes a vacation home ends up costing you thousands and thousands of dollars a year in cash flow and real costs. Renting the same vacation home, on the other hand, could cost far less.
So what are the advantages of renting a vacation home? There are many:
1. You can go to a different place every year: Some folks like to vacation at the same place every year. That's fine, but if you want to see more of the world, owning a vacation home will tie you down to a specific place. And since the cost of owning a vacation home can stress your finances, you may not be able to travel abroad or do other things you want to do in life. 
2. Less worries: If you own a vacation home, there is always the worry about a storm, fire, damage, a burst pipe, or some other problem. A broken appliance will materialize just at the time when your credit card is maxed out. When you rent, your worries evaporate the moment you hand the keys back to the rental agent and get your security deposit back. 
3. Less cost: As noted above, even if you pay $3000 a week to rent a home "in season" it can often be less costly than owning the same home. to own that home, you may be shelling out $20,000 a year in real costs, and using it less than a few weeks. You'd be better off renting! 
4. Flexibility: If you own a vacation home, that monthly payment and expenses trudge on and on, with no letup. If you lose your job or need money for something else (child's college) you don't have any flexibility in spending, unless you want to sell the vacation home, which can be costly, difficult, and sometimes take years. If you rent your vacation spot, you can make instant decisions about spending.
So there are pros and cons of owning a vacation home. What many people fail to do is do the math on such a purchase. They look at the vacation home and say "Gee, I can afford the payments" (often based on rosy rental scenarios) but they don't ask themselves "Hmmm... would it simply be cheaper to just rent the same house year after year?"

And the same is true for primary residences, particularly condos. People for some reason think that owning a place is a sign of status, while renting is some sort of mark of shame. But if it costs $1500 a month to own a condo, and only $900 a month to rent it, chances are, it is better to rent, particularly if you are only going to live there for a few years.

And on that note, we should discuss time shares and vacation condos. Time shares, as I have noted in the past, can be an utter rip-off. People on vacation see posters inviting them to a seminar. Or worse, are enticed to a "vacation" at the time-share which is little more than hours of high-pressure sales pitches.

The lure is that you can "buy" a part of a vacation home ("just the weeks you want!") for a tantalizing small amount of money, usually $25,000 to $50,000. The catch is, of course, is that there are fees for cleaning, etc., and like any other condo arrangement, these fees can be raised over time.

Just for laughs, we looked at one such resort in the Keys. They wanted nearly $30,000 for a week "time share" and $800 a week in maintenance fees, with no guarantee that the fees would not go up. $800 a week in and of itself is a good down payment on a motel room (which is really all the time share was) and if you threw in the payments on the "purchase" price, you were actually paying more than someone would to rent the same place.

Plus, if you multiplied $30,000 times 52 weeks, you'll see that the timeshare people are selling each motel room for the equivalent of 1.5 million dollars (!!!) or enough to buy a really, really nice house in the area. While they may be selling you only a "part" of the home, in terms of time, they are jacking the price up considerably as part of the deal. Such a motel condo might sell for $300,000 outright, making its weekly value only about $6,000. Why would you pay five times as much?

Timeshares are nearly impossible to sell, too. Most of the companies hawking "timeshare resales" are merely con artists hoping to milk another mark for yet more money.

The timeshare people will argue that you can "trade" weeks at one resort for weeks at another - for a small fee, of course. But when you factor in all the costs, it really is cheaper and more flexible to just plan a vacation from scratch, decide where you want to go (instead of picking from a list or going to the same place every time).

Vacation Condos have all the problems of timeshares and vacation homes, with the nightmare of condo boards and politics thrown in. If you rent a place or go to a resort or hotel, you don't have to think about the condition of the roof or how you are going to pay for it. In the dictatorship of a resort or hotel, the decision to replace the roof is made and completed without a lot of hemming and hawing. In a condo, such decisions are only made after many loud and noisy arguments, bad blood, and generally, when the roof finally caves in. And of course, you have to pay a special assessment for it, because most of the members want "low condo fees".

Hotel Condos are also an interesting gimmick. We have some here on the island and no matter how I do the math, they never work. The condo is rented out as a hotel room by the resort, so basically you are owning a part of the resort. The resort takes a huge chunk of the nightly rack rate, and you have to maintain the condo in a generic, motel-like appearance.

Worse yet, since the resort is operating as a hotel and needs the rooms to make money, you are limited in the number of days you can actually stay at the place. So if you stay over a certain period of time, you have to pay the hotel for lost revenue. As an eventual retirement home, they are not an option.

And while I have "cranked the numbers" on these "investments" many times over the years, they never made sense in terms of cash flow. It was always more expensive to own one of these places than to merely rent it.

And that's the rub - paying more for the privilege of owning real estate, as opposed to renting it, makes no sense whatsoever.

But, I suspect that like with primary home ownership, there is a status "cost" involved. People will pay extra to own, because they want the bragging rights of home ownership, which has some psychological benefit to the owner.

So that's how I see it. Owning a vacation home can be a nice luxury, but it can be a great way to squander cash. But do the math first. Buying a vacation home could be a costly mistake.