Monday, January 2, 2017

All News is Fake News - Chickens Come Home to Roost


The "mainstream" media has been peddling stories that border on fake news, for decades.  Today, the far-right just cuts to the chase and makes things up.  The chickens have come home to roost!


Fake news made a lot of real news last year.   People actually believe in made-up stories, and it seems some fake-news sites are getting giddy with how far they've been able to push ridiculous stories and get people to believe in them.   I wonder if the point of these stories isn't really to get folks to believe that Hillary chops up children into small bits in the basement of a pizza shop so much as it is to illustrate that people will believe anything you print, and have been doing so for generations.

In my last posting, I took the New York Times to task (I am sure they are shaking in their boots!) over a very biased and slanted story that was clearly written with a goal in mind - to make us all weepy over a convicted criminal and to get us to believe he is a "victim" of the system.   It is not "news" reporting, but propaganda of the worst sort.  We are treated to page after page of how bad the criminal has it in life, but nary a word on the injuries suffered by the real victim of the crime - other than to lightly mock his stress and paranoia after having his home invaded (and showing us all where he lives, so we can "self-investigate" in person!).

The punchline is, of course, that the criminal is already out of jail so the "injustice" if there was one, has been corrected.  But sadly, I think the publicity from this article will not help, but hurt his chances of turning his life around.  

Stories like this - that are so blatantly biased and tell things from one point of view - hurt journalism in general.  But this has been the norm in journalism for decades.   What pisses people off about Fox News, other than it is totally unwatchable for anyone older than age eight - is that it uses the same subtle biases the other news shows have been using, since television news began.   A raised eyebrow here, a knowing look there, emphasis on the right word - is all it takes to make a benign story sound sinister.

And sometimes, news shows dispense with "impartiality" altogether.   When we watched "live streaming" of the election results from PBS on YouTube, the hosts of the show abandoned all pretense of impartiality by declaring the night an unmitigated disaster.  Granted, the idea of a Trump Presidency is still hard to swallow, and no one for a moment believes that Public Broadcasting is anything today but a de-facto left-leaning television and radio network (and hardly "Public" anymore but in the pocket of major donors and content providers like NPR).  But it is hard to accept their criticisms of Fox News when they engage in the same sort of partisanship.

For decades, many on the Right complained that the "mainstream media" had a liberal bias.   And for decades, the mainstream media denied this, which of course stretched their credibility even further.  Having a slightly liberal bias is not a bad thing in and of itself, failing to own up to it is another.

How does bias work?   It begins with the editors or program directors.   Someone in any news organization has to decide what stories are worth reporting, worth investigating, and what will get published.   And someone has to decide what gets on the front page and what gets "buried" in the back.   In the modern media age, someone decides how long a story runs - does it survive the "news cycle" or does it peter out and die?

"Legitimate" news outlets don't necessarily make up the news, but then again, they don't have to.  They can decide something is not news or something trivial is news.   It leaves you with a little less flexibility than the outright fake news sites, who can make up compelling stories at a whim, but it still leaves you plenty of options as to how to shape public perception.

And much of these decisions as to what is and isn't news depend less on political predispositions than on what they believe will sell with the public.   As I have learned from monetizing this blog, there is a lot of money on the table in the news business, and you can make a lot of money telling people what they want to hear.  Moreover, this pressure is often subtle.   The editor with the highest standards of integrity will tell you that he does not let crass commercialism affect his editorial decisions, but subliminally, he knows which articles "sell" newspapers or generate good ratings or high click-rates.   And he also knows the penalty for not putting up popular content - the country is littered the corpses of dead newspapers, magazines, and cancelled news and commentary shows.  Ratings or die, that is the name of the game.

Oftentimes, you can create legitimate "fake news" merely by being opaque or not explaining things completely.   For example, in the New York Times article I mentioned in my previous posting, they minimize discussion of the real victim of the crime, his injuries, and his concerns.   It really isn't even brought out, until the very end of a very, very long article, that the fellow isn't even in jail anymore and that no real injustice has been done (other than that nasty victim of his crime stabbing him in self-defense! Boo!  Hiss!).

Similarly, during the election, much was made of Hillary's e-mails, but in the news blurbs you saw, you would come away with the impression that having an e-mail account was something only criminals would do.   The media never explained very clearly exactly what crimes Hillary had committed or why an e-mail saying that Bernie Sanders was a jerk was such a bad thing.   When the FBI announced they had "found more e-mails" it was akin to saying they found more child porn under her sofa.

And the media loves being vague - a form of passive-aggression - as they can keep you watching by telling you half the story.  The New York Times article is a case in point - starting out with a "teaser" and then embedding the "rest of the story" in page after page of weep-fest for the criminal in the case.

Or take how the Nightly Nooze is formatted - They have less than 22 minutes to "inform" you and much of this is wasted by an anchor giving you a sound bite of a story, then handing off to a "reporter in the field" and after suitable introductions, she says basically the same things the anchor did.  "Back to you, Jim!"  It is bad enough the format of the show is so short and interlaced by commercials, but to waste valuable airtime in this nightly ritual of back-and-forth between anchor and "on scene" reporters is just unforgivable.

The latest gag in the "bounces off me and sticks to you" genre of political think - perfected by Trump during the last election - is to call all mainstream news "fake" - usually by people who are "true believers" in alternate reality news sites.  I think the mainstream press really thought they could kill off fake news by bringing attention to it.  But it backfired in this age of schoolyard name-calling.

Perhaps George Bush started it - taking John Kerry's attack on Bush's lack-of-war-record and bouncing it back with Swift-boating, which the mainstream "liberal" media reported with bated breath.   The media was complicit in this event - which turned the tables 180 degrees until Bush was the war hero and Kerry the coward. 

And so it went in the election.  Donald Trump is accused of being a "birther" and he simply turns it around - "You're the birther, not me!" and people actually believe this.  This is the new normal we have to face.  Ronald Reagan may have been the teflon President, Donald Trump is the trampoline one.   Whatever you throw at him, bounces off and hits you instead.

Fake news didn't emerge from a vacuum, but rather from the incubator of network news and tabloid journalism. Dan Rather, of all people, put the nail the coffin of real news by relying on an obviously fake document to try to implicate Bush on the eve of the election.  Dan Rather - what a piece of work - and the Father of Fake News as we know it.

Of course, Rather had to "retire" from the news, and his producer at 60 Minutes was fired.   There is (or was) at least some modicum of accountability in "real news" for false reporting.   No one was every fired over swift-boating John Kerry, however.  Which illustrates the power of real fake news - you don't have to answer to anyone.

But sadly, I don't think "real news" is going to kill off "fake news" anytime soon.

The Problems With the Victim Mentality

A recent New York Times Magazine article tries to manipulate us into believing that a man who breaks into someone's home and assaults the residents is the actual victim.  Nice try.

A man, drunk out of his mind, breaks down the back door of a house - tearing the dead bolt out of the wall.   He staggers in, grabs a frying pan, and tells the homeowner it is time for him to be "punished" and clocks him on the head with a frying pan.

Quick:  Who's the victim here?

The New York Times would have you believe it was the guy who was breaking-and-entering, the fellow who clocked the guy with the frying pan.   After all, he has PTSD! 

The article is an exercise in intellectual dishonesty from the get-go.   From the way the article is laid out, to how it relates the story (in fragments, to keep you reading) it is designed to get you all weepy for the criminal and feel nothing but hatred for the victim - who unreasonably wants to press charges.   As a special bonus, they "Dox" the victim by showing a picture of his house!  Nice work, New York Times!  Protecting the identity of victims of crime - NOT!

The story is laid out in NYT Normal - a huge photo of the criminal involved, along with weepy black-and-whites of his Mom and whatnot.   The way the story is told is dishonest.   They tease you by telling the first part of the crime - leading up to the assault on the homeowner - then stop short and intersperse 89 pages of the story of the criminal.   The theory is, after reading about what a rough life he has, we are supposed to excuse his criminal actions.

When they finally get around to telling the story of the crime, the actions of the criminal are minimized and the injuries to the homeowner are not even mentioned.   He gets clocked on the head with a frying pan.  Did this cause a concussion? Fractured skull?  Brain injury? We will never know.  However the injuries to the criminal are related in great detail - injuries the homeowner inflicted trying to save his own life and that of his friends.   What a rotten guy, right?

Worse yet, they mock the homeowner for his paranoia and anxiety he suffers as a result of the break-in. His PTSD is dismissed out of hand, of course.   That of the criminal is what really matters.

Other sites online which discuss this story omit the mention of the criminal clocking the homeowner with the frying pan, characterizing the incident as "mistakenly walking into the wrong house" - also failing to mention kicking a dead-bolted door to pieces.  Oh, right, it's a Change.org petition - proof that far-right Republicans are not the only ones to engage in "post-truth" behavior.  All news is fake news, to some extent, in that they try to sell us on a way of thinking.  The far-right just isn't as good as it as the Grey Lady.

This sort of dishonest article is part of a trend of the media to get involved in small-town crimes and bring them to a national audience, while at the same time, making the criminals out to be the victims.   Perhaps this started with In Cold Blood - Truman Capote's story of the brutal murder of the Clutter family.   The story started out as a crime drama "whodunit?" but quickly morphed into something else.   Capote seemed to express a deep sympathy for the killers, and less for the victims.  There are rumors he was sexually attracted to one of the killers and may have in fact had an in-jail affair with him.   Hardly impartial journalism.

Crime stories do suffer from an intractable problem - the story quickly becomes all about the criminal and less about the victim.   In fact, good defense attorneys try to put the victim on trial, if they can get away with it.   And in a murder case, the victim is not around to object too much.  Criminals become famous - even celebrities.   The victims are forgotten - and often their character is trashed in the process.

The problem with this "victim" narrative is multi-fold.   While PTSD is nothing to laugh at, not everyone who comes back from war ends up committing crimes.   It is akin to other victim-mentality excuses based on race, disadvantaged youth, childhood abuse, or whatever.  We are told these excuse bad behavior on the part of the criminal - but they fail to explain how other people in the same situations end up not committing crimes.   They become post hoc justifications - and a good defense attorney today goes searching for victimhood on the part of his client as part of his defense strategy.

Oh, and yes, many criminals are aware how this works, and will use their victimhood as a means of excusing their behaviors.  This may be startling news to you, but not everyone who serves in the military comes from the best of backgrounds.   Some people who go into the military were assholes - living on the wrong side of the law - before they ever went in.  It could be PTSD that causes them to commit crimes when they got out.  Or maybe they were just prone to that sort of behavior beforehand.  There is no one simple answer.

Mark's Dad had to jump out of a flaming bomber, after seeing the pilot's head blown off.   He spent nearly four years in brutal conditions, seeing his friends shot in the head while the Germans marched him on a "death  march" from camp to camp, as the Russians advanced on Germany.  While he was no doubt affected by this ordeal, he felt no need to rob a liquor store or beat the crap out of anyone as a result.

Does PTSD give everyone a get out of jail free card?  Some would argue just that.  The criminal's lawyer in this case felt he should never serve a day in jail as the result of his actions.   Sounds like a good deal to me - you get to commit whatever crime you want to and just show your card to the nice Policeman who has to let you go.   Fortunately, that is not the law of the land, just yet.

Being a victim, positing yourself as a victim, or embracing victimhood is bad for the individual and for society.   It is a form of externalizing of the first order, for starters.   The "victim" can say that none of the poor choices he made in life were his fault, but rather the fault of external forces - the actions of others, seen or unseen.   He is given - quite literally - a "get out of jail free" card.

It never leads to reform or improvement, either.  Once the "victim" is convinced that nothing he did was his own fault or within his control, then he can rightly give up on trying to improve himself.   We establish a role to play and people live up to the expectations of that role.  You tell a young man that it is expected of him to be a failure because of PTSD, growing up in the ghetto, coming from an abusive home, or whatever, and odds are, they will live up to that expectation.

Victimhood hurts the "victim" the most, as it gives them carte blanch to stop trying in life.  You tell them they are damaged goods and not responsible for their actions - what do you expect will happen?   It is the same problem we have with our mental health system, which seems more interested in making people into chronic patients than into curing them.   You put a label on someone, you label them for life.   It is not healthy.

It is like drug addiction.  In addition to chemical dependency (which a lot of people think is overstated) is an emotional dependency.  The "role" of drug addict is strictly defined, and part of it is the pattern of quitting and then lapsing, again and again, which gains sympathy and attention - feeding back exactly the wrong impulses and rewards for bad behavior.

Worst of all, victimhood is bad for our society.   To begin with, when enough people start identifying themselves as victims, our society is damaged as an increasing number of people become non-functional or engage in criminal activity, drug abuse, or whatever.   Victimhood is a form of learned helplessness - the idea that you should just give up trying as nothing you do in your life is going to change it anyway.  When enough people decide they are victims, they become passive and easy to manipulate and society as a whole suffers.

(A conspiracy theorist might argue that is part of the plan - get us all to feel as victims in our own lives, having no control over our destinies, and then be all-too-willing to sign over our freedom to a socialist nanny state.  But we don't believe in conspiracy theories around here!).

The victim mentality also hurts the Democratic party.   Democrats have for too long engaged in this idea that everyone-is-a-victim and that (a) we should feel sorry for them and (b) we need to shower them with government money.  It is not a popular opinion outside of the liberal enclaves of the East and West Coasts.   And that is why Democrats keep losing elections.   Even the victims are starting to tire of this message.  Black people didn't vote for Donald Trump, but they failed to vote for Hillary, as they failed to see (as posited in another New York Times article) that "anything had changed" after years of paternalistic government thinking.

To be sure, the Republicans and Donald Trump will engage in victim-hood, often as much as the Democrats.   The Externalizer-in-Chief regularly goes on Twitter to whine and complain about how "unfair" life has been to a Billionaire.  And he regularly sells this idea to his followers, telling them that it is not their fault they lost their jobs, but the machinations of Mexico and "Gina" who made them victims.   Their lack of job skills and work ethic - and the propensity to strike at the drop of a hat - had nothing to do with it.  And it goes without saying that you might as well not bother learning any new job skills for jobs are that currently going unfilled, as you are a victim and it is best to wait until Uncle Donald brings your job back from Mexico.

They may be in for a long wait.

This story has a happy ending.   The criminal was convicted for home invasion and given a six-year sentence.   That seems about right for invading someone's home and hitting them with a frying pan.  If he behaved well in jail, he could be out in as little as three years.   And three years of sobriety might be helpful.

But he didn't even have to serve those three years - his conviction was changed to "attempted home invasion" and he was released after only five months in jail.   Five months in jail for clocking a guy on the head with a frying pan.  I'd say he got off light.  He's damn lucky he isn't dead.  Break into someone's home, they have a right to kill you in self-defense, which he almost was.

In a way, I now feel sorry for the guy, because his life from now on is going to be that much harder.  No longer in the spotlight, no longer a celebrity criminal/victim, he will find that the post-celebrity lifestyle quite a letdown.   Right now, I am sure he is on top of the world, being featured in the New York Times - and garnering a lot of sympathy.   What happens when this dies down?  Does he become one of those pathetic has-beens, sitting at the end of the bar, saying, "Did I ever tell you about the time they did a feature article about me in the New York Times?"   The searing spotlight of celebrity can burn you - ask any celebrity in re-hab.   I sincerely hope he can turn his life around, and not be the subject of a "what ever happened to....?" article a decade from now.

And I hope the guy who got clocked on the head with the frying pan can find some closure.  Because, it turns out, he is also a veteran and fellow Marine who probably has issues of his own.   And he certainly didn't deserve to have some asshole bust down his door in the early hours of the morning and clock him on the head with a frying pan.

So where's the injustice?   The New York Times would have you think the guy was still in jail or facing serious jail time, when he is in fact, out of jail and supposedly being treated for alcoholism and PTSD.  Sounds like things went pretty well - a brief sentence for a real crime.   Why the 800-page article in the New York Times this weekend?   Slow news day, I guess.

But let me tell you where the real injustice is - if it were you or I who committed this crime, we'd still be in jail, because we are not sympathetic "victim" criminals and thus are not fodder for a newspaper story or in-depth article or pro bono representation by the largest law firm in the State.

And that is yet another problem with the victim mentality - it provides selective justice only for those people who are camera-ready and come across well on television or have a compelling back-story.

The rest of us can go fuck ourselves.  Which I guess, ironically, makes us all victims!

UPDATE:  Two things still bug me about this story:

1.  Why was it published now, as opposed to months ago when these events were current?  Since the criminal in the case has been let go after four months in jail (a light sentence for home invasion and assault) it seems that no searing injustice has been done and in fact the system worked.

2.  If this guy was black, would the media have fallen all over him?  It helps to be a photogenic white guy, don't it?

Just a thought.




Sunday, January 1, 2017

Mail Box or Door Slot?


Do you put a mail box on the front of your house or just a mail slot?

The US Postal system is an interesting beast.   Having worked in my life delivering newspapers, pizzas, and spending some time at their prime competitor, United Parcel, I have some sympathy for postal workers.   It can be a really difficult job sometimes - "through rain and snow and gloom of night" - or 105 degree summers here in Georgia.  It is a lot of walking.

People expect so much of the postal service.  For 47 cents, they expect people to take an envelope and transport it thousands of miles to the correct recipient, within a day or two, and get pissed off when it doesn't go as planned.

To me, that seems like a pretty incredible bargain for so little money.   But what the hell do I know?

When we lived in Virginia, we had a mailbox at the end of the driveway.  On our street, some houses had mail boxes on posts at the end of the driveway.  Some had mail boxes affixed to the house near the front door.   Some had mail slots in their door.   It made no freaking sense - there was no commonality or consistency with the delivery type.   If everyone had a mailbox at the end of the driveway, the postman could deliver the entire street in about ten minutes.   As it was, he had to walk the route, and it took over a half-hour and he walked across our lawn, leaving a trail  (I eventually had to put up a fence to make him walk around!).

In some regions and in Canada, they are more consistent and logical.  They install huge postal boxes for the entire neighborhood, at the end of the block.   You walk or drive to the box (you generally drive by it every day anyway) and pick up your mail.  Far more efficient and cost-effective.

But no, we can't have that here in the States.  People freak out when you say they are going to cancel Saturday delivery (who the hell else delivers on Saturday?) and yet they also scream bloody murder when you raise the postage even a cent.  You can have low rates or Saturday delivery - pick one.

Sorry, but I am on the postal service's side on this one.  People are a bunch of whiny brats who want everything their way and someone else to pay for it.   Sadly, this "someone else" usually ends up being me or someone like me.

Can Saturday delivery.  Standardize delivery options.   Rationalize delivery service.  Keep the costs low.

Because we can't do this, the USPS is forced to seek revenue elsewhere, by forcing people to get postal boxes if they travel a lot.  Mail holds and forwarding are being limited and these limits being enforced.   Sending things to "general delivery" (which many winter residents do here) is discouraged and renting a mail box is being encouraged.

You can see why - when people won't let the USPS rationalize home delivery, the have to seek revenue sources elsewhere.

Here on the island, we have a postal box next to the front door.  The previous owner had one there and the Island Authority doesn't allow boxes at the end of your driveway.   When we traveled it was a hassle to put a hold order on the mail, as it created a burden for our mail person, and sometimes we would have to drive into town to get our mail when we returned.

I thought about putting a mail slot in the front door and just let the mail accumulate.  Very little of what arrives by mail is urgent these days - even checks can wait a week or two to get deposited.   I drove around the island and looked to see if other people had mail slots, as I didn't want to create a burden for the postal workers. 

What I found was startling.

A lot of houses - maybe 25% or more - had a mail slot in the garage door.   That's right, in the garage door, not the front door.   I thought about it and it made sense.   You put the slot in the garage door, put a laundry hamper under it, and when you leave for a vacation or whatever, the mail goes into the laundry hamper.   How easy is that?

I went to Home Depot and bought a mail slot (Lowe's did not carry them!) and installed it in the garage door at an easy height to reach for the mail person.   I put it close to the middle, so the mail would land between the cars, not on them.

 A bicycle basket, mounted on a hinge, catches the mail from the slot!

I also found an old bicycle basket and some brackets and screw-gunned that to the door.  It catches the mail and hinges as the door opens so the mail does not fall out.  When we leave, the basket collapses and a folding card table and laundry hamper catches all the mail.  UPDATE:  Turns out not to be an original idea.  Not only did I find a lot of photos on the web (such as the one above) of people doing similar things, but they sell actual products for this purpose.

This is easier than doing "holds" or "forwards" on the mail, and cheaper than the USPS "priority" forwarding.

For packages, I have a label on the inside flap instructing the mail person to put packages inside the screen porch, away from prying eyes (another good reason to have a screen porch!).  Keeps it out of the rain, too.  A friend usually comes by and brings the packages inside in a day or two.

The postal carrier likes this arrangement better as the garage is closer than the front door, and also the mail slot never gets filled up with mail, like our small postal box does.

 And since we are are a "managed service point" the postal carrier comes every day!

One new program the USPS has implemented is "Managed Service Points".  As you might imagine, walking a route every day to deliver mostly junk mail might seem like waste of time.  And some postal workers have decided - in the past - to just skip to the chase and skip certain houses or a number of houses and then deliver the mail the next day, or the day after - or never, by throwing the mail in the dumpster or hoarding it in their homes.

Even if there is no mail to deliver, the postal workers are supposed to visit each house to see if there is outgoing mail - a relic of a bygone age.   I am one of the few to have outgoing mail - or at least I used to.  So my carrier chose me as an "managed service point" and every day, the carrier has to scan the bar code inside my mail box to prove they actually went there.   Sort of like the watchkey boxes they give to night watchmen, to prove they made their rounds.   It is a good idea, of course.

So far, this mail slot idea has worked out well for us.  But frankly, I am more interested in the overall robustness of our postal service as a whole.  A central mailbox for the block or neighborhood would be a more efficient idea, and one that is being used in many new neighborhoods in the US and Canada.   And an easier way to hold mail - for periods longer than 30 days - would be appreciated, too.

In the meantime, the mail box slot in the garage door seems like a great idea to me!

The Transgender Thing... Can We Talk?



When rational discussion is not allowed about an issue, it drives dissent underground.
 

One of the reasons the Democrats lost the last election, and have been losing elections, is not only that they appear to be tone-deaf to their constituents, but that even when they are willing to listen, they won't let people talk.   Political correctness (a term coined in Communist countries, by the way) dictated that certain subjects were taboo to even talk about except from one side.

This entire "transgender" thing is a case in point.   We are not allowed to discuss this in rational terms, unless we are celebrating the "bravery" of a tired has-been Olympic athlete who had his dick cut off.

Whoops.  I went there.

You see, having your genitals mutilated is not the equivalent of actually changing your gender.   Maybe it is something you would like to do, maybe not.  Myself, the idea of slicing up my body in general repulses me, which why I am not a big fan of tattooing and piercing.   At my age, just getting a shaving cut to heal properly in under three weeks is considered a big victory.  I am not sure why anyone in their right mind would engage in any form of  "elective surgery."

And that is what "gender re-assignment surgery" is - elective.   And no, it doesn't "re-assign" your gender, it just gives you fake genitals to play with.  If that's your thing, fine.  But expecting the rest of us to pay for such expensive surgery - forgetabouit!    And under Obamacare, this is exactly what was happening.   Should plastic surgery or breast implants (strictly for cosmetic purposes[1]) also be covered under Obamacare?   Where do we draw the line at what is "health care" and what is just nice things we'd like to have?

And regardless of where you think that line should be drawn, the discussion of where to draw the line should not be squelched.

And yes, this includes sensitive issues such as abortion and birth control.   Should publicly funded health care pay for such things?   Taking aside the moral objections of some taxpayers to the scheme, is this a necessary health care issue or an optional one?   Again, even discussing this is taboo in our country.   And it is a discussion worth having.

Some forms of contraceptives are inexpensive or even free - people hand out condoms for free all over the place.  Go to any gay bar - they have them in a fishbowl by the door like after-dinner mints.  The idea that people "can't afford" condoms is kind of ludicrous.

Other forms of contraceptives are more expensive and have their own issues.  IUDs can be kind pricey, and they do have some associated risks.  Birth control pills are fairly inexpensive (particularly at Planned Parenthood) but the doctor visits required to get a prescription can be kind of pricey - if not covered by insurance.  On the other hand, is $15 a month too much of a burden for most people?   You can spend more than that on a meal at the drive-through at McDonald's, for two people on a date.

So this begs the question:  If national health insurance didn't cover birth control, would people really stop using it because of this?  Are people really going to say, "Well, I got pregnant because I didn't want to get a free condom or spend $15 a month on birth control pills?"

Again, discuss amongst yourselves, but have the discussion and don't just shut it down.

From my perspective, growing up in the 1970's and having worked briefly at a Planned Parenthood, birth control seems to be readily available to young folks at a moderate cost.   Financing this through health insurance seems like overkill.

But what about abortion?  This is where it gets difficult.  As an outpatient surgical procedure, it is remarkably inexpensive, given the risks involved and compared to relatively milder procedures such as a colonoscopy, which can run $1500 or more.  Whether either should be covered by Obamacare is something that should be debated (incidentally, unnecessary colonoscopies can actually be risky, and Obamacare mandates these are free for anyone over 50, which has in turn lead to a lot of unnecessary colonoscopies, as the "imaging centers" doing these procedures don't make money by turning away patients).

Would people be more motivated to have an abortion if it were "free"? - I don't think so, and I am not trying to make an analogy between the two procedures.  Do people have a "moral right" to object to a national law paying for a procedure they believe is akin to murder?   Well, they have a right to object, of course, but not necessarily a right to prevail.

Personally, I think one way to end all of these debates and to cut the cost of Obamacare is to make it more like old-fashioned "Hospitalization Insurance" - catastrophic coverage for high medical bills incurred from car accidents, serious illnesses, and the like.   What most people are afraid of, when it comes to medical care, is not how to pay $200 to see a doctor, but how to pay $15,000 for hospital stay.   And it is the latter, not the former, that is bankrupting hospitals and the medical system.  Maybe if we went to a high-deductible, stripped-down, "basic" medical coverage, it would solve a lot of these social issues and economic issues at the same time.

The big problem with Obamacare is not that it covers too little, but covers too much, and once you tell pharmaceutical companies you will pay whatever they charge - just send the bill to Uncle Sam - they will charge what the more than the market will bear.   Do you think our prescription opioid epidemic would still be around if these pills were paid for with hard cash instead of co-pays?  I doubt it.

Just a thought.   But once again I digress.  We were talking about transgender issues, right?

One reason the Democrats lost and lost big was that they embraced a lot of fringe Left issues that they felt were the "right thing to do" and came from the heart.   But sadly, they didn't really give people time to discuss, debate, or even process these things before making mandates about transgender bathrooms and the like.

To be clear, no one being "against" transgender people by discussing the issue.   And it is an issue that has been around since the dawn of time.   There have always been "Tomboy" girls and "Sissy" boys, throughout the history of the world.   Today, we label them as "transgender" before they are out of the crib.   For some, it may be a phase they are passing through.  For others, a character trait.   And there is nothing wrong with a woman who has masculine characteristics or a man who has feminine ones.   In fact, they seem to be an essential part of our society throughout the ages.

They have also been persecuted, bullied, and beaten, throughout the ages - and that's just wrong.

We should accept people for who they are, and just leave it at that.   But the issue isn't as simple as that.

What do you do with a sixth-grader who likes to wear his sister's dresses?  Does he get to wear them to school?  Or a third-grade girl who "identifies as a boy" and wants to join the Cub Scouts?

The Democrats see this as a simple black-and-white issue:  You let these kids do whatever they want to do, identify with whatever gender they want to, and let them use the gender-assigned restrooms and locker rooms they choose to.   It sounds simple, but simple answers to complex problems are usually the wrong answers.

To begin with, is age eight a sufficient level of maturity to decide one's gender or sexual orientation or both?  This is a serious question - but one we are not allowed to ask.   Kids at that age are not sufficiently mature to make life-changing decisions, which is one reason minor children are basically considered property in this country until they reach the age of majority or are legally emancipated.  And even in the latter case, a child has to be at least 16 (14 in some States) - far above elementary school age - for emancipation.

We don't trust kids to drive cars, vote, or sign a binding legal contract until age 18, but at age eight, we are going to let them choose their gender?  For life?   This seems a bit premature.   Some young girls are "tomboys" at that age and then when they reach puberty, have different ideas.   Others remain tomboys, regardless of whether they are Lesbians, or merely prefer more traditional male-centric activities.  Some decide they want to live in a male gender identity.  This is a personal choice you are free to make- at age 18.

And there is no hurry to make such a decision.  So why the rush?   The idea that you will be "scarred for life" by not being allowed to "choose your gender" in grade school seems unproven to me.   Yes, discrimination, taunting, bullying, and assaults on kids who were "different" in the past was not a healthy thing.   We survived in spite of this.   The idea that a child who feels different or who is bullied has no other choice but to commit suicide in this day and age, seems to me, ridiculous.   Things were a lot worse when I was a kid!

(Oddly enough, in my parent's and grandparent's generation, gender issues among children were treated more liberally to some extent.   Young boys grew their hair long and wore dresses until they were nearly grade-school age.   At some point, they would be transitioned to "knickers" which were pants that went down to below the knees.   Getting your first set of real trousers was a sign of the transition into manhood.   Today, gender-specific clothing is assigned almost from the cradle.   How times have changed!)

But the flip side of the coin is this:  If we allow children to "decide their gender" in grade school, does this mean we have to force schools or other organizations serving kids to accommodate this choice?  Can't a young "transgender" boy[2] wear pants for six hours a day and use the boy's restroom?  Is that really going to scar him for life?  And if so, how?   He can wear all the dresses he wants to, at home.

Are the concerns of other parents irrelevant?   A young kid sees a boy showing up in class one day as a girl.  This might be more than a little confusing to a child.  Moreover, what does this have to do with primary school education?   Kids go to school to learn, not to express their gender identity.

When I was in grade school, there were always the boys who liked to jump rope with the girls and the girls who wanted to play rough with the boys.   By the end of grade school and the entry into junior high school, people tended to conform more to gender stereotypes, due to social pressures.   The rough-and-tumble girls still went out for field hockey and basketball, of course.   And the "kitten-like"[3] boys certainly weren't on the football team.

And yes, I know some people who struggled with the conformity of High School - one young man who almost went insane with the taunting and bullying.  But whether it was the taunting and bullying that made him crazy, or just an underlying mental illness, it is hard to say.   Others breeze through high school, being wildly popular with the "in" crowd while at the same time being outrageously gay.   Usually they are in band.

(And it goes without saying that the loudest bullies in high school are the closet cases).

There is also the issue of parents "pushing" a child in a gender direction.   In the past, it would be the parent pushing the child to conform to their biological gender roles.  Today, it is politically correct parents who seem to rejoice in celebrating their child's "differentness" and encouraging it at every turn.  While it is nice that parents today can be supportive of "queer" kids, maybe the should be more neutral instead of cheerleading for one side or another.

Because what it gets down to, is we are experimenting with people's lives without really understanding the ramifications and outcomes.   You can raise your kid to be "transgender" even if he/she is not inclined to be so.  But even if they are, once they leave the hothouse of some urban/suburban liberal bubble, they will have to interact with the rest of the world, and they may find the rest of the world is not as accepting as their parents were.

But let's not talk about that.   In fact, let's not talk at all.  We'll just sit in our separate camps and talk to ourselves.

That's sure to resolve things.  Right?


[1] Yes, my late sister had breast implants after she had a mastectomy due to breast cancer.  This, however, was not "breast augmentation surgery" but "breast reconstruction surgery".  There is a huge difference between a cancer victim getting their breast back and a stripper getting bigger titties so as to attract men. 

[2] For the sake of clarity, I am referring to biological gender. This whole he/she nonsense is another thing that is just getting out of hand.

[3] A term coined by Dave Sedaris to describe the boys in his school who were forced to take speech therapy classes to cure them of their incurable lisps.


UPDATE:   We should understand the terms of discussion before discussing it.  And the entire thing with "transgender" issues is that it encompasses a variety of issues and orientations.   Of course, most people want to talk about the sex part, because that is what people are interested in.  Or they want to talk about some ugly guy with a beard wearing a dress.  There are a lot of misconceptions.

1.  There are heterosexual males who like to wear women's clothing while having sex with a women.  They are not gay, they are not transgender, they are not trans-sexuals.  They have no desire to be a woman or act like a woman, they just have a fetish for women's clothing.  Since this mostly occurs behind closed doors, you do not hear from these folks much. I guess you could call them sexual transvestites.

2.   There are gay men who want to have sex with other men.  They do not want to be women or act like women or dress like women.   These are not transgender, transvestites, trans-sexuals or whatever.  These are merely homosexual men.

3.   There are women who want to have sex with other women, but do not want to be, act, or dress like men.  These are Lesbians.

4.  There are men and women who enjoy having sex with men or women, but are not interested in cross-dressing or acting like the opposite gender.  These are bisexuals.

5.  There are people of either gender who want to dress and act like the opposite gender, and it may have nothing to do with sex or sexual orientation.   They just like to identify with another gender.

6.  There are a very small number of people born with hermaphroditic genitalia.  In the old days, doctors would often "correct" this by surgically altering genitals.   Often such folks were forced into gender roles they did not feel comfortable with.

7.  There are also people born with extra "male" and "female" genes (XYY and XXY) which does not necessarily affect sexual orientation, but may affect the physical appearance and body of the person with this genetic makeup.

8.  There are people who are heterosexual but have interests that are not considered stereotypical for their gender.  They do not identify with or want to be an opposite gender, they merely are interested in things that are not considered typical by our society for their gender.   Women who want to repair trucks or men who want to arrange flowers are usually assumed by society to be homosexuals, but such is not always the case.

9.  There are people who cross-dress as a hobby, for entertainment purposes, or just to have fun.  They have no sexual interest in cross-dressing or any desire to assume another gender.  For them, it is a hobby or even a profession.  These you could call female impersonators (or male impersonators).

10.  Believe it or not, there actually exist something called heterosexuals, who are comfortable with their biological gender and are sexually attracted to the opposite sex.   Yes, freakish, I know. But there you have it.

11.  There are people who are any mixture of all of the above.   People are unique and really can't be categorized or pigeon-holed.

The mythology among much of the general public is that gay men all want to be women (not true) or lesbians all really want to be men (again not true).   The mythology is also that people who cross-dress (which both men and women do, although women can dress in a male manner and face less approbation for it) are homosexual or bi-sexual or that their cross-dressing is somehow a sexual act, which is may or may not be.  It is a lot more complicated than that.

And it goes without saying, that most people really don't care one way or another what you do in your personal life, but they don't necessarily want to deal with your personal issues in public.

And yet, that fails to explain why Bruce Jenner gets such high ratings on his or her TeeVee show...

Maybe it is like when people slow down to see a car wreck?   Maybe.


Saturday, December 31, 2016

Back to the Future, Part II


It seems we are re-living the 1970's all over again.
 
Back when I was a kid in the 1970's, we had Jerry Brown as Governor of California.   Cuomo was Governor of New York.  And of course, Trudeau was Prince of Canada.   And a guy named Donald Trump was making waves in New York City.

Not much has changed since then, it seems.  There is still a Cuomo in the governor's mansion in Albany and a Trudeau in Ottawa (thank God our Canadian friends don't have political dynasties like we have here in the States!).  And Jerry Brown - the original, not a copy - is again in the governor's mansion in California - this time as a fiscal conservative who is helping to rescue the State from insolvency.

Other relics from that era are starting to resurface, including self-proclaimed "revolutionary" terrorists who are up for parole.  Judith Clark, who assisted in an armed robbery as part of a plan to ignite a race war in America and start a "revolution" recently had her sentence commuted by Governor Cuomo - and may be eligible for parole as early as next year - which no doubt is good news to the families of the two police officers and security guard mercilessly gunned down during that robbery.  Cuomo argued that Clark had been "reformed" in prison and at age 67 was no longer a threat to society.   One of the other robbers is now a professor at Columbia University (where else?) and another was the step-father of the late Tupac Shakur - illustrating the whole apple-and-tree analogy.   You can't make this shit up.

Leslie Van Houten, who helped kill two people as part of the Manson killing spree - also in an effort to start a "race war" in America, is actually been recommended for parole, but was turned down by Governor Jerry Brown, the same Jerry "Moonbeam" Brown who used to be governor of California back in the 1970's.  Another Manson follower is also up for parole, but it appears Brown would block that, if granted.   Brown apparently has learned from experience in office and wisely decided that a terrorist, murderer, and self-proclaimed "revolutionary" should stay in jail for the rest of their lives.   He needs to have a chat with Cuomo and tell him how it's done.

While Brown seems to have learned from the lessons of the 1970's, a new generation of Left-wing politicians are still somewhat tone-deaf.   Commuting the sentence of Judith Clark is a slap in the face to the family members of the officers and guard who died during that robbery.  And tonight, the Governor and a group of his elite friends will be having a private cocktail party aboard the brand-new 2nd Avenue subway line in Gotham City (unless the Joker intervenes!) - but of course, it is invitation only.  Thank God the Democrats are not elitists!

One reason Democrats have been losing elections across the country is that they come across as disengaged from the lives of ordinary citizens.   The perception is that Democrats believe that everyone in jail is either innocent or has been reformed and that criminals should go free.   The reality is, of course, that crime has dropped dramatically since the 1970's.  But reality is not what swings elections - perception is.

Moreover, there is something unseemly about people who commit atrocious crimes just for the hell of it.   The man who shoots a store clerk during an armed robbery because he needed drug money is no saint.  But next to the guy who shoots people just because he likes to watch people die, he looks a lot better.   Similarly, killing innocent people because of some "revolutionary" or political cause (particularly one that is far-fetched) is also obscene.   Just because the political system isn't to your liking, doesn't mean you have the right to kill people.   You could try voting or organizing a political party - or just compromising.

Today we rightfully call such people "terrorists" and condemn them soundly.  And no, terrorists should not be let out of prison because they seem like nice people - in prison.

Jerry Brown seems to "get" this.   While you may feel "sorry" for these young women who were drawn into the cult of Manson, the horrific crimes they committed are unforgivable.   Life in prison is not too harsh a punishment for people who stab a pregnant woman 17 times.  And no, we don't feel better about them because they "couldn't go through" with cutting Sharon Tate's baby from her womb.   You simply can't reform that level of mayhem.

Democrats will keep losing elections and lose what little control they have in this country so long as they appear to be living in isolated bubbles.  The Democratic party needs to shed its image as the party that is the friend to criminals, and the enemy of the police and the tax-paying citizen.  Until that changes, nothing will change.