Wednesday, May 22, 2024

Hotel Reservations Versus Campground Reservations

Nights versus Dates = Confusion!

We have made a number of reservations to go camping this summer and I noticed something odd. Mark went to hotel/restaurant management school, and when we logged on to, say, recreation.gov, he would say, "we are arriving on August 21st and staying three nights!"  Meanwhile, the recreation.gov site wanted to know our arrival date and departure date.

This resulted in confusion, as, for example, under the hotel reservation rubric, the reservation is "Arriving August 21st and staying three nights" whereas in campground lingo, the reservation would be, "Arriving August 21st and departing August 24th" - which sounds like four days - because it is. To someone versed on hotel reservations, well, it sounds like you are staying four nights.  And indeed, we ended up making a mistake in our reservations, leaving a "hole" in our itinerary as one reservation had us checking out on a Sunday, and Mark assumed that meant we were staying Sunday night and departing Monday.

And that is not the first time this has happened. Last year, we ended up "homeless" for one night because we got confused between "departure date" and "number of nights" as one campground was indeed using hotel reservation software.  Fortunately, we were able to stay over another night - but were only made aware of the issue when the campground manager asked us why we hadn't checked out yet!

Why do hotels do this whack-a-doodle way of taking reservations?  Beats me, but I suspect it is because they sell hotel rooms based on the number of nights you are staying.  You are buying a night's sleep basically and then getthefuckout, dammit.  With campgrounds, I guess, they want to make it clear what day you are arriving and what day you are departing, so people don't stay over an extra day or reserve an extra day they don't need. Campgrounds sell days, hotels sell nights.

There are exceptions of course. One campground, using a hotel reservation software, reported the reservation in terms of arrival date and number of nights, rather than giving a departure date. Some hotels, on the other hand, give all three pieces of information - arrival date, number of nights booked, and departure date (and checkout time!).  Hey, it pays to be clear!  Still another place listed each day you were staying, which was kind of confusing.

I tried to make a reservation on recreation.gov for one night and it bounced it right out.  I had to select two days - arrival date and departure date - otherwise it thought I wanted the campsite just for the day.  So, two days equals one night - right?  It's not like it is confusing or anything!

How these systems evolved is an interesting topic.  I suspect since the hotel and camping worlds don't intersect very often, they evolved in different ways for different reasons.  Hotels want to know the number of nights so they can multiply that by the "rack rate" and calculate your bill.  Campgrounds want to make sure a site is vacated on a certain time and date so the next camper can occupy it - I guess.

To me, as an ordinary human being, the "number of nights" is confusing as all get out.  I have to count on my fingers to figure out what my departure date is, if I am spending a number of days at a hotel.  When I ask the desk clerk for clarification, it goes like this:

"So, I am departing on Sunday, right?"

"You are booked for three nights."

"Yes, three nights, so today is Thursday, that means I depart Sunday, right?"

"Three nights, sir!"

"OK. that's Thursday, Friday, Saturday nights, departing on Sunday.:

"Three nights!"

"Never mind, I figured it out myself!"

It gets more complicated if you are staying a week or longer.  I don't know why hotels don't just publish your arrival and departure dates instead of hoping you can count the days on your fingers.  It just seems like it would eliminate a lot of confusion.

But maybe that's just me.

Tuesday, May 21, 2024

Marginal Pricing And McDonald's

 

When each consumer pays the most they are willing to pay, you have an optimized economy - in theory.

We went to a funeral in Atlanta last week (more on that in another posting) and after picking up the Dowager Widow, we stopped at the McDonald's in Darien to get breakfast.  I went inside to use the kiosk and was shocked to see that every breakfast sandwich was over $5.  Not for the "value meal" but just the sandwich.  Five bucks for a goddamn McMuffin!

The people in the drive-through were all paying that, too.  The drive-through window and the inside menu promote the "value meals" which in many cases were over $10 for a sandwich, hash browns, and a coffee.  Ten bucks!  For fast-food!

The reason I went inside was to use the kiosk as they have a "deals" section there and lo and behold, you could get a sausage McMuffin with hash browns for $2.79 or about half what they wanted for the sandwich alone on the main menu.. So I ordered three and we all ate for $9.04 or what the guy in the jacked truck idling in the drive-thru was paying for just one "meal."

I was willing to explore and take my time and got a better price.  Of course, this was without coffee, but we already had coffee.  For some weird reason, Americans have gotten used to the idea that a cup of coffee, which was basically free at one time, is now worth $2.50 or more (often far more) just for a basic brew.  At the Georgian Terrace hotel, regular coffee is $6 a cup at the restaurant.  When did this happen and why did we go along with this travesty?

Oh, right.  Starbucks.  Sold us the idea that coffee should be expensive, when it was once a cheap staple.

But I digress.

The guy in the drive-thru is late for work and just orders "whatever" because he is in a hurry and is suffering from low blood sugar. So he pays "whatever" and maybe grouses about high prices but doesn't do anything about them.  For example, making meals at home is less than half the price of eating out, as I noted before.  The only reason we didn't do that as well was that we were leaving on a week-long trip and the refrigerator was empty.  And $2.79 wasn't going to break the budget, particularly in comparison to the nightly rate at the hotel we were staying at.

What breaks the bank is when you go through the drive-through every day and are hungry and end up over-eating and over-paying for bad food.  When a restaurant becomes your kitchen, bad things happen.  But then again, I am lucky I have someone in my life who cooks.  I just do the dishes.

But speaking of hungry, the folks at Ambetter sent me the video above.  As part of the My Health Pays program, you watch these short videos or read pdf files about healthy practices and in exchange, they credit a debit card with cash.  I use this to pay our cell phone and hotspot bills.

What is odd about these tutorials is that so few of them are about exercising and eating right or other things we traditionally think of as "healthy" habits.  Rather, a lot of them deal with mental health and emotional issues and a whole helluva lot deal with spending, saving, and money.  Funny thing, but if you are broke and in debt you end up unhappy and this leads to stress which leads to health issues.

I know this as the two major health issues I have had (so far) were stress-related.  Crank up the stress levels and my gout or diverticulitis goes nuts.  Since retiring, both have abated.  Funny how that works.

The above video talks about HALT - Hungry, Angry, Lonely, Tired - the four factors that can cause you to impulse-buy something you don't really want or need.  I wrote before how car salesmen use these factors - keeping you at the dealer for hours (five or more!) until you are, well, Hungry, Angry, Lonely and Tired.  Having a meltdown at the car dealer isn't some aberration, it is how they sell cars.

You reach a point where your blood sugar is low and you are tired and you lose it - lashing out at the car salesman.  But instead of leaving, you end up buying the car, partly out of embarrassment and partly to "show them who's boss!"  Sounds stupid, but people do it - we all do it.  It is a game they play with a stacked deck and you can't win - which is why buying a car from an individual seller is often a better deal - unless they try to play the same games as well.

So while the "invisible hand" of the marketplace works in theory, and each consumer pays the best price they can afford for a product ("a car for every purse and purpose") in reality, emotions skew the whole deal.  And fast-food places have learned, since the pandemic, that there is little point in engaging in a price war, when you have hungry customers who no longer know how to prepare their own meals and are demanding food - now.  Just charge them as much as you dare and chances are, despite all the bitching and moaning, they'll pay.

And on the app or kiosk, you hide a daily "deal" that few will bite on, other than cheapskates like me, so you can cover your ass and say you have affordable options for the less-fortunate.

Until people stop acting emotionally and start acting rationally, nothing will change.

Monday, May 20, 2024

The Drop Shipping Scam-Scam

Drop-shipping isn't really a scam.  Selling people seminars on how to drop-ship, is.

I ordered two filters for an old "HEPA" filter machine that we got years ago as a scratch-n-dent deal for a few bucks when Mark worked for Sheets 'N Things.  God, I guess that was 25 years ago.  Anyway, the machine takes special filters (unlike the cheaper ones, where I just wedge in standard HEPA furnace filters) which can cost as much as we paid for the damn machine.  So I searched online for a cheaper alternative. I opened windows in Amazon and eBay and finally found the cheapest price on eBay.  Amazon was almost twice as much.

I shoulda checked Walmart.

A few days later, a package arrives from Walmart, addressed to Robert Shilling, at my address, with the filters.  What happened?  Arbitrage or Drop-shipping.  Someone (Mr. Shilling?) saw that the price on Walmart was lower than eBay and set up a listing on eBay (not hard to do for standardized products) and then when I bought, he merely had it shipped from his Walmart account and pocketed the difference, which was only a few bucks at best.

If you can program a bot to do this, you could rake in the dough - as even a dollar per transaction would add up quickly, if it was automated.  I wrote about "Arbitrage" before when I ordered an eBay item and it arrived by Amazon as a "gift" order (so I never saw the actual price the drop-shipper paid).  It isn't a scam per se, as I paid the price agreed upon and received the goods I wanted.  It was my fault that I didn't cross-shop on other platforms.

Economists would smile.  In a perfect economy, each consumer pays the most they are willing to pay for a product (more about that in tomorrow's posting).  So if I was willing to spend time on researching prices more, I could have paid less.  But for other consumers, the hassle isn't worth it, and many people just click on the first hit on Amazon and hit "buy it now!" and don't bother to cross-shop, believing (falsely) that they can afford it.

Perfect economic balance, in the warped minds of economists.  But I kid....

To me, it is fascinating that someone thought this up.  And I see no problem with it, either.  The only thing that concerns me is that perhaps Amazon or Walmart are the ones behind this - trolling eBay to see if listings are going for higher prices than on their own sites and then putting up listings on eBay which lead back to an Amazon or Walmart purchase.  Since the Internet monitors everything you do (or at least your browser does) it isn't hard for them to figure out if you are cross-shopping on different sites.

Amazon, Walmart, eBay, and PayPal all desperately implore me to "remain logged in" to their sites, even as I close the windows.  I wonder why that is?  Oh, right, they have my best interests at heart and want to help me out and say, it is convenient to remain logged-in, right?

Right.

But getting back to topic, yes it is true one could make money from Arbitrage. In the early days of the Internet, a friend of mine reported that they knew someone in Maine who went to Renys department store (a Maine institution) and bought women's and children's clothing off the discount rack. They would then list them on eBay with a substantial markup.  If they sold they made money.  If they didn't, well, Renys' generous return policy (at the time) allowed them to return items that did not sell.  So it was a heads-they-won, tails-they-didn't-lose kind of situation.  It was the early days of online Arbitrage.

Today, of course, this has gone automated.  You can even set up AI bots to answer customer service inquiries.  So the opportunity for an individual to make money from this is limited.  It is like Bitcoin - you could have made millions if you "mined" coins decades ago. Today?  That ship has sailed and everyone and their brother thinks they are going to be the next Crypto "whale."

That ain't gonna happen.

Levi Strauss made his fortune, not in gold mining, but in selling blue jeans to gold miners back in 1849. That was where the real money was - in supplying the transportation, supplies, and information to would-be miners, who stripped the countryside bare looking for that elusive shiny rock.  Nearly 200 years later, not much has changed.  You can makes lots of money trading in gold - or lose it all.  But you are guaranteed to make a profit selling the idea of making money in gold to would-be goldbugs or silverbugs or crypto-bros or meme-stonk traders or whatever.

And not surprisingly, people are making coin by selling the idea of drop-shipping to the plebes as a "work from home" scheme to make money.  People pay them money to attend an online "seminar" about Arbitrage.  Then people pay a monthly fee to use their "system" to drop-ship.  And since it is only you and a few million other suckers who signed up for this, surely you can corner the market, right?

That's why I have no beef with drop-shippers.  Because market competition exists, if one person offers an arbitrage product for $5 over cost, another will go to $4.  Then another to $3 and maybe $2.  Pretty soon, the arbitraged listing is indistinguishable from the source price listing and there is little profit to be made in Arbitrage.  The invisible hand of the marketplace does its job - eventually.

Not only that, but even dunderheads like me eventually catch on to what is going on and start go check out alternative sites to ensure they are getting the best pricing.  A sure sign a product is being arbitraged is when you see multiple identical listings on eBay for the same product at slightly different prices.

I want to thank a reader who sent me a link to a YouTube video which uses an AI-voice to sell an Arbitrage (drop-shipping) tutorial and service.  I would reproduce the link here, but if I did so, it would generate more traffic for that YouTube site.  The above image was obtained by image searching on "shopify drop-shipping tutorial" and was the first image that came up, out of pages and pages of images - each linked to a separate YouTube video.  Good thing to get in on the ground floor!

It is like a link a "reader" sent me about crypto - "11 things that can go wrong with crypto."   It sounded promising, until you read the link and realize it is saying that crypto is the best thing in the world and all those people crying in their soup just didn't do it right.  Sounds a lot like what MLM-Scheme "Huns" say when a victim bankrupts themselves. "They just didn't work their downline hard enough!" or some such nonsense.

Or the "Buy Ugly Houses" billboards - selling the idea that somehow you can find an endless supply of distressed homes that can be bought for half of their market value, easily fixed up, and flipped with no effort on your part.  Good luck finding people to work on your house, in this market!  Good luck finding an endless supply of cheap fixer-uppers as well!  Better off to sell the idea of house-flipping than to flip houses yourself.

You'll never go broke selling the idea of how to make money.  That's for sure!

If it was such a good idea, why would anyone tell others about it?

Monday, May 13, 2024

The Crime Wave of the 1970s

Crime rates today are at an all-time low, but are edging up.  Nothing like the crime rates back in the 1970s, though!

When I took Criminal Law from Professor Starrs, he explained how crimes are prosecuted and why many crimes go unsolved and unpunished.  To begin with, we have to define what a crime is, by passing laws against certain acts.  Marijuana was once illegal in many States (and still is, at the Federal level) as was alcohol.  "Social" crimes like adultery, miscegenation, sodomy, gambling, and the like were once on the books, but have since been deemed unconstitutional or repealed.  So the first step is to determine what crime is.  And you'd be surprised as to what is and isn't a crime.

Next, we have to detect it.  If someone is victimized (burglary, robbery, assault, etc.) then they may report the crime.  But of course, many crimes go unreported, for many reasons.  If a crime it not reported or there is no immediate victim, police have to detect it, either by interrupting the crime in progress, or determining that a crime has occurred.  While we have so many Constitutional protections in our home, most of them don't apply once you are in your car.  Fail to signal a lane change, and you can get pulled over, at which point an officer can "detect" the presence of a secondary crime. So many criminal cases begin with a traffic stop.

But the police officer has discretion on who and when to charge - and this is where it gets tricky and allegations of discrimination kick in.  If you are a small-town cop and pull over the Mayor's son - who is drunk - you might decide to escort him home, rather than piss-off the guy who signs your paychecks. On the other hand, a poor kid from the other side of the tracks is likely to spend a night in jail.  Yea, the system is unfair.

It is a human thing.  And I've seen firsthand, how some lesser cops will make up their mind early-on as to who is guilty, if anybody.  Before he gets out of his car, the officer might have decided how things are going down - and arrest the victim, not the perpetrator, if anyone is arrested at all.  And like a dog with a bone, once they have decided, they are reluctant to give up on that notion.

Presuming what occurred is defined as a crime by the law, and presuming the police detect the crime, and presuming the perpetrator can be ascertained, and presuming the police decide to arrest the perpetrator, we are still far from over.

The prosecutor may decide ("prosecutorial discretion" or Nul Pros) not to bring charges, either because they are trivial (e.g., trumped-up "resisting arrest" charges) or because there is insufficient evidence to win at trial.  Prosecutors, like the police, have finite resources to bring to bear, and no prosecutor is going to waste much time on your stolen bicycle, particularly if it doesn't look like an easily winnable case.  The law of scarcity kicks in.

Assuming you've gotten by all those hurdles, it may turn out the perpetrator will work out a plea bargain and the perp will avoid jail time as a first offender or the like.  They might even have their record wiped clean.  Again, limited prosecutorial resources, so they punt when they can, and move on to the next case.

But let's assume that even that hurdle has been overcome and it actually goes to trial.  It may be months or even years before it is resolved.  And in many criminal cases, less than half of defendants are found guilty by a jury.  Of those found guilty, a certain percentage may have their conviction overturned on appeal.

So the odds of going to jail are somewhat long, and many criminals realize this. It ain't like Blue Bloods or Law and Order, where criminals are caught, tried, and convicted within an hour-long show. People like to believe that, and the "system" would like you to believe that - fear of being prosecuted is the only thing keeping many people on the straight and narrow.

As I noted before, my friends at the IRS explained that their two greatest weapons were withholding and the inordinate fear people have of the agency.  Without the former, no one would be able to pay their taxes come April 15th.  Without the latter, well, people would realize how unlikely it is to be audited and how unlikely it is you will end up owing more taxes (unless you are an outright tax cheat!).  Fear keeps us ordinary citizens in line.

The funny thing about these probabilities, though, is they don't stack.  If you commit crimes over and over again, the odds of getting caught go up with each crime.  Eventually, if you crime long enough, you will be caught. If you are a habitual speeder, you may not get caught every time, but eventually, you will blow through that speed trap and get busted.  Ask me how I know.  I drive the speed limit these days.  Then again, it ain't 55 MPH anymore.

That's the thing about criminals, though.  A young man may appear before a Judge and claim to be a first-time offender, but in reality, he is a first-time caught offender.  He may have committed numerous crimes, but was only caught for one.  People start to lose patience for criminals, particularly habitual criminals.

Historically, crime rates in the USA have decreased since the 1700's.  It sounds silly to go back that far, but you have to realize how lawless the United States was back in the "Frontier" days.  We romanticize the cowboy era where shootouts took place at the local saloon.  We even do re-enactments of these crimes for our amusement.   But murder is murder and it is never pretty.  We romanticize the shootout at the OK Corral, but not the slaughter of Sharon Tate and her friends by the Manson "family."  Give it time, it will be an attraction at Disney World, just like "Pirates of the Caribbean" - a ride that makes a joke of rape, robbery, and murder.

We took a trip down the Natchez Trace, a walking path that is now a parkway.  Back in the frontier days, traders would built rafts and float goods down the Mississippi to sell in New Orleans - and then sell the wood from their rafts.  Loaded up with their entire income for the year, they would walk back North along the Natchez Trace.  Robbers would await them, of course, and murder them and take their money - disposing of the corpse in whatever way they could.  There was not much of a police force back then, so such crimes were rarely detected or prosecuted.

Crime dropped off, year by year, decade by decade, century by century, as America became more "civilized" and police forces more organized.  Crime reached a nadir in the late 1950s and then inexplicably rose - nearly doubling - from the 1970s through the 1990s and then inexplicably dropping off again.  There has been a slight rise since the pandemic, but nothing like the old days. This hasn't stopped Fox News from sensationalizing crimes and claiming there is an epidemic of crime.

Like I said, fear of prosecution keeps a lot of citizens in line.  Remove that fear, and many people will commit crimes.  In the 1970's, it wasn't unusual to see cars stripped down to the chassis, sitting on their frames, on city streets of New York.  I recall driving under the UN building in the early 1980's and seeing a late model Ford LTD wagon, on its roof in the median. The thieves had no jack, I guess, and found it easier to just roll over the car to remove the wheels.

"Broken Window Policing" has its roots from back then. The city, on the brink of bankruptcy, had few resources to combat crime or tow away stolen and stripped cars.  So people got the idea you could get away with this - ordinary people.  I recall an article from New York magazine of that era, where they left a used car in a fairly middle-class neighborhood and planted a hidden camera to see what happened. It was stripped, of course, and what was surprising was that the criminals who looted the car were not gang-bangers from Harlem but ordinary folks from the neighborhood. One photo caught a businessman in a suit and tie, carrying a briefcase in one hand, and the rear seat cushion of the car in question, in the other.  Hey, everyone else is getting something out of this, why not me?

Some argue that the cumulative effects of tetra-ethyl lead in gasoline lead to the crime wave. Others, the burgeoning drug epidemic, particularly the crack epidemic, of the era.  Still others claim it was lax enforcement, over-burdened police and prosecutors and "soft on crime" judges.  New laws were passed, such as the "three strikes and you're out" law - which allowed prosecutors to get long sentences for habitual criminals.

And crime dropped.  Some say it was get-tough-on-crime laws that lead to the decrease in crime rates.  Others point to demographics - the aging of America.  Still others to the decrease in lead exposure, or decreased drug use among the young.  Frankly, I think it is a combination of all of these, to some extent.  But the bottom line is, a criminal in jail isn't committing crimes.  And if you lock up a young criminal until he is an old man, he isn't likely to commit crimes as an oldster.

Some have argued the "three strikes" laws are unfair, and some States have repealed them. Opponents argue that some poor slob who "just stole a loaf of bread to feed his family!" is unjustly incarcerated for decades.  But if you scratch the surface of these stories, the "loaf of bread" was a hijacked bread truck, and the perpetrator, while having a number of children by different women, hasn't visited any of them or provided as much as a slice of bread to them, either.  And bear in mind, that if he was convicted of three crimes, odds are, he is responsible for a dozen or more - perhaps dozens.  I don't lose any sleep over the three strikes law, mostly because I don't commit crimes - certainly not three felonies!

In some urban areas, certain types of crime have skyrocketed. In LA and San Francisco, people leave the trunks or tailgates of their cars open to deter smash-and-grab thieves, who will do hundreds of dollars of damage to a car, to steal tens of dollars of goods stored in the trunk.  The Police, hounded on all sides for various high-profile cases of abuse, are "quiet quitting" and doing the minimum to investigate and prosecute "mere property crimes" which are inevitably blamed on the victim (for having the audacity to have a job and try to own things).  Ditto for "porch pirates" who are rarely caught or prosecuted, even when caught on a doorbell camera.

In New York and some other cities, it is the "knockout game" which, unlike smash-and-grab crimes on the West Coast, provides no profit to the perpetrator.  Kids in gangs punch people on the back of the head (or the front) trying to "knock them out" which they often do, leading to head injuries and even death, as the victim hits the pavement.  Again, it seems people are getting away with this and thus it proliferates.  Steve Buscemi is the latest victim of this trend - a crime with no rhyme or reason.

It should be noted that many of these "knock-out" crimes are racially motivated - aimed against Asians, often perpetrated by crazy homeless people.  Homelessness, which is a drug and mental health problem - and not an economic one - is another reason for the uptick in crime in recent years.

While these crimes are horrific and concerning (and garnering a lot of press) they do no reflect an alarming increase in the crime rate as touted by the right-wing press.  Nevertheless, they should be vigorously prosecuted.  I believe that some police forces, feeling embattled by the "defund the police" (a nonsense slogan if there ever was one) movement, are taking hands-off approach to a lot of minor (and major) crimes as a means of rallying support from voters - who will vote for "get tough on crime" politicians as a result.  If so, this is a particularly evil thing to do.

The recent, albeit mild (compared to the past) rise in crime can't be attributed to lead in gasoline as we took that out in the early 1970s.  Demographics are not in play, either, as the nation has aged further and the younger generation is smaller than in the past.  It would seem that lack of enforcement and the "let everyone out of jail" movement may be to blame, instead.

Some on the left like to argue that crime is caused by economic conditions - that poverty breeds crime and people from disadvantaged backgrounds "can't help it" and should be treated leniently as a result.  The problem with this argument is that it is a slap in the face to those from the same or similar backgrounds, who don't commit crimes and work hard (and often suffer from the acts of criminals).  The young man accused of assault and battery is painted as the victim of a difficult childhood - and should be excused for his actions.  But what of his brother who experienced the same privation and yet declined the life of criminality and violence?  How is that fair to him?

The reality of crime is that the victims of crime are often from the same social class and neighborhood as the criminal.  Whites fear black-on-white crime, but the reality is, blacks victimize more blacks than anyone else.  I suspect the same is true for whites - particularly with financial crimes.  It is like violence against Muslims.  As a Muslim, you are far more likely to be killed by a fellow Muslim (from a different sect, e.g., Sunni versus Shi'ite) than by a US-made reaper drone.

All that being said, it is an election year, and I recently received a "survey" online asking me about my opinions about various local and national politicians as well as issues.  One of them was about "getting tough on crime" versus "addressing the root causes of crime" - you could see where they were going with this.

In other words, they've turned this into a political football.  Republicans welcome an increase in crime as a means of getting elected.  The "tough on crime" stance is what got both Nixon and Reagan into office (both of whom today would be called "RINOs" by the Maga-set).  It is a formula that works.  Like I said, it seems the police are complicit in this, particularly in larger cities, by taking a more laid-back approach.  But some prosecutors are making things a lot worse by trying out crackpot theories which result in revolving-door justice.  Criminals are released without bail (or much reduced bail) on the grounds it is more "fair" to the poor.  And maybe that is true, but it also means that a criminal need only plead poverty to be let out.  Time to put those crackpot theories to rest - the result in more crime.

And they lose elections as well.

Sunday, May 12, 2024

College Bankruptcies - the Enrollment Cliff

Demographics are only part of the college bankruptcy crises.

More than a decade ago, I opined that the next wave of bankruptcies would be colleges and universities.  At the time, we were going through the bankruptcy of GM and Chrysler's second bankruptcy as well.  The "Big-3" automakers had a storied history of offering the wrong products at the wrong time (big gas-guzzling cars and SUVs of low quality) as well as blowing billions on pie-in-the-sky ideas.

GM, for example, was reported to have spent as much on Saturn than they would have just buying a controlling interest in Toyota.  GM spent billions in a deal to acquire Fiat, then spent an equal amount to get out of the deal - money that Fiat used to buy GM's competition, Chrysler.

In the 1970s, the "big-3" couldn't compete with the Japanese, so they offered such "innovations" as opera windows, landau bars, and vinyl roofs, hoping that a plethora of tchotchke would bondo-over shoddy build quality and decades-old engineering.  It didn't work.   The bonus was, of course, they were horrifically expensive as well.

Today, the "pimp barges" of that era are just starting to become collectible in spite of themselves.  Those cars are sort of along the lines of the Edsel - not necessarily desirable, but more of "can you believe they built this?"

College educations were falling along similar lines, starting in the 1990s and accelerating into the 2000s.  I have no sympathy for anyone "struggling" with student loan debt if they took it out in the last decade or so.  The media has been rife since the early 2000's, with articles about how worthless some college degrees are and how overpriced they are - and how student loan debt is like a life-ring made of lead.  Young people today have no excuse for not knowing.

Like the 1976 Monte Carlo, a liberal arts education today looks attractive from a certain angle and distance, but up close, the cracks appear in the facade.  Kids are majoring in useless majors, such as "gender studies" or "African-American studies" or the like - toxic degrees in many cases that are best left off your resume, as they mark you as a potential troublemaker, not a productive employee.  They also show a lack of sound judgement.

And before you flame me, I will admit that there are one or two jobs out there for someone with those "credentials" - a company might want a "diversity training" officer with such a background.  But such jobs are few and far between and like a "communications" degree, the colleges are cranking out more graduates in one year than there are jobs in the industry overall.  No, you are not going to be the next Dan Rather by going to Newhouse School.

And to boost corporate profits, many companies are laying off their "diversity training" officers and eliminating other touchy-feely job titles, which were good for corporate PR, but not so much for the almighty share price.

Consider my hippie brother (update: no longer stinking!) who has a PhD in puppetry and miraculously .found the one job on the planet that requires that credential.  We are all happy for him that at age 50 he found this job.  Now, if he can just keep working until age 80, he can pay off those student loans.  I kid, but the thrust is true - there are jobs out there for some more obscure degrees, but there ain't many of 'em - and a ton of applicants.

It reminds me of my friend who was a bassoonist for the late Syracuse Symphony (which folded when they could not pay union wages and could not put butts in the seats in the audience or find corporate sponsors willing to throw money at it).  He told me they had an opening for a principle violinist for the orchestra.  They received thousands of resumes, of which hundreds were eminently qualified and of which they selected dozens of finalists.  One lucky person won the job, but even with union wages, it was not a great living.  At least back then, student loans were not a thing.  Today they are.

Time was, a liberal arts degree - or any degree - got you a job.  Back in the post-war era, you could graduate from college and get a salary job and "work your way up" from the mailroom to the executive suite.  You could succeed in business without really trying - or at least that was how it appeared.  And yes, companies had a lot of "dead weight" and indeed, they treated employees better, in some regards, and invested more in their human capital.

I went to school at General Motors Institute, a college started by the then-largest automaker in the world as a feeder for their engineering talent requirements.  Although many if not most graduates (or dropouts, like me) ended up working somewhere else, it was said that GM still benefited from increasing the pool of Engineers as a result.  They felt they were doing a public good.  Those days are over, although the school still exists (as Kettering Institute) and co-op programs exist at other colleges and universities as well.  I highly recommend checking them out, if you feel you can't "afford" college and also want some real-life work experience.

On the other hand, not many places are offering co-op programs for English Lit majors.  And this is a general trend.   College is so expensive today that students are forced to make hard choices.  Sure, there are always the rich kids who can afford to party for four years (and their parents gladly pay, to get them out of the house).  But the near-wealthy and middle-class can't afford to do that.  And I've seen middle-class kids try to emulate the lifestyle of their trust-fund frat brothers through the use of student loans.  It does not end well.  Bad grades and a useless degree - and a lifetime of crippling debt - are not a fair exchange for four years of binge-drinking.

Three small liberal arts colleges I am familiar with have gone bankrupt - with only one being saved so far. My sister's Alma Mater, Sweetbriar, went bust, but was saved at the last minute through donations from wealthy alumni.  The school had the money, but it was tied up in an endowment that limited the school to an all-girls college.  Fortunately, a judge threw that limitation out, and with alumni donations, they are back in business - for now.

Cazenovia College - in my old hometown - went bust when they borrowed millions of dollars to install a new equestrian center and other improvements.  They apparently didn't do the math on how to pay back that money.  It is akin to how many "brick and mortar" stores went belly-up in the last few years.  Pundits blamed the problem on Amazon, but the reality was these companies were often taken private, saddled with staggering debt, and then unable to pay it back.  Such was the case with Caz College.

Our lake house was in Aurora, New York - the one North of Ithaca, not near Buffalo.  It was a funky place, home to Makenzie-Childs pottery.  The founders, Richard and Victoria (or as we called them, "Dick & Vic") were our next door neighbors.  The town was host to Wells college, named after and founded by, one of the founders of Wells Fargo as a "seminary" school for his daughter to attend.  The town was also home to a motley collection of old hippies and colorful characters.

It was more than a decade ago when we lived there, but the school was struggling even then.  They went co-ed to try to attract more students and tied-in with Ithaca College and Cornell to allow students to attend classes there.  One wealthy Alumni, Pleasant Rowland (who sold her American Doll company to Mattel for nearly a billion dollars) pumped money into the school, keeping it afloat and paying to renovate school buildings, including the old hotel and restaurant.

As her reward, the locals hung her in effigy, claiming that making the hotel ADA compliant was "attracting too much tourism" and "ruining" the local vibe.  So Pleasant took her marbles and went home - and donated hundreds of millions to other places where people weren't so stupidly obstinate.

Wells just announced they are closing for good.  Maybe it would have closed anyway, with or without Ms. Rowland's millions.  On the other hand, pissing off your number one alumni surely was a stupid move.  What will happen to the school is anyone's guess.  No doubt the mansions along the lake (many used as school buildings) will become vacation homes for those awful "tourists" that the "locals" were trying to keep out.  Time will tell.

The big problem for the school was that they were offering liberal arts degrees, and as a small college, they had very high tuition costs.  In today's dog-eat-dog world, student-consumers are looking for bang-for-the-buck and a "meh" degree from an unknown institution isn't very valuable anymore.  And whether you like it or not, everything has a value, even (and especially) college degrees. So just get over that and stuff that "education for education's sake" nonsense in the toilet.  Ordinary people can't afford that. And no, neither can our government.

When you are in a job interview and the first thing you have to do is explain what your Alma Mater was all about, you are at a distinct disadvantage.  When I interviewed at Carrier and the USPTO, they understood what GMI was all about.  But at the law firm, it was "what the hell is that?"  Meanwhile, at many an interview, they would see "Syracuse University" on my resume and smile and say, "Let's go Orange!" and then want to spend the rest of the interview talking basketball and Coach Jim Boeheim - two topics I know little about and care less.

Sad but true - your college education will be judged by how notable your school's sports team was, regardless of your major.  Employers know "brand name" schools, even if it is only from watching sports on television.  When I entered The George Washington University (yes, "The" is part of the name) we had no real basketball team to speak of.  The new dean made it a goal to have a division-A team and succeeded.  When I interviewed with employers, it was the same deal, "How about those Colonials?   Made the playoffs!"  Less spoken about was the notoriety of the faculty of the law school, which was a shame as they had some notable professors there.

Fair?  Of course not.  But that's life - unfair.  Good-looking people are hired and promoted over less-attractive folks.  You will be discriminated against based on your race, religion, sexual orientation, appearance, or whatever - despite laws to the contrary.  And your education will be evaluated, in some situations, based on how well-known your school is.  A degree from Harvard still has panache even it the school itself has acquired a patina.

But again, this is just one factor and colleges are facing a perfect storm of a number of factors conspiring against them.  And the biggest factor is the so-called enrollment cliff, a demographic drop in the number of high school graduates in the coming years.  Compounding this problem is the drop in foreign students (thanks to xenophobic anti-immigrant politics) who were previously a cash-cow for many universities, as they generally came from wealthy families and paid full tuition without scholarships or government subsidies.

The vaunted "US education" is losing it shine in many countries overseas.  I am reading online stories from Indian students who came to America to get technical degrees at great expense, only to find employment difficult in the States and nearly impossible back home.  Many US students are questioning the value of a college education, seeing the $100,000 or more (sometimes per year!) as better spent on a down payment on a house or a nest egg for retirement.

The old adage that a college degree will earn you more money over time is based on statistics from the 1960's and 1970's and is far less true today.  Maybe this will turn around, but with so few people willing to get into the trades anymore and so many young people wanting "desk jobs" the labor rates have inverted.  I noted before the law business sort of cratered when everyone decided to go to law school and the medical profession seems similarly affected.  Once the ticket to an upper-middle-class living, a law degree or medical degree is today at best, a ticket to stay within the struggling middle-class.

Meanwhile, the heavy equipment operator is showing me photos of his vacation home and $100,000 pontoon boat, towed behind his pickup truck that cost as much.  Who's the idiot now?  And we wonder why "rednecks" are voting for candidates who promise to cut taxes for people making over $400,000 a year.  Those country folks are raking it in more than we suspect.  The new poor are the professional class living in the city.

There is, of course, one more factor and that is endowments.  Traditionally, colleges and universities had endowments which were big piles of money they had invested.  Often, they could survive just based on the income from the endowment. In fact, one famous school has no tuition as their endowment is large enough to cover all expenses.  In addition, wealthy alumni (who either came from money or made lots of money by dint of having a college education) would donate money or give huge sums to have a building constructed with their name on it.

Today?  Less so. Many schools are burning through their endowments, trying to hang on, hoping that "down the road" somehow things will turn around.  Meanwhile, the new generation of alumni are so broke they cannot afford to donate to their old school.  When you are still paying off student loans well into your 40's, you can't afford to answer the call of the Alumi association.  By charging such enormous tuition and encouraging students to take out loans, colleges, in effect, were borrowing from their future alumni donations.

So take all this and throw it in a blender.  Colleges and Universities are facing big problems.  But for the most part, the initial failures are limited to smaller liberal arts colleges, "women's" colleges, and historically black colleges.  These are small tragedies being played out in small towns and cities across America, making local headlines and then everyone forgets about it.

In the short-term, these closures are good news, ironically, for larger schools.  The few hundred students at Wells will no doubt transfer to some other school, and big universities like Syracuse or Cornell may benefit.  It is like a herd of gazelles - the lions take out the weak and infirm first, which allows the young and swift to escape.  Real shame about grandma, but hey, more grass for us to eat!

The crises will become more evident when a major university goes bust - or a university system, such as SUNY profiled in the article linked above.  Maybe then, college deans will sit up and take notice and maybe change will occur.  Sadly, this will likely lead to a call for more government bailouts or "free college" as they (used to) have in the UK and elsewhere.

Or maybe colleges will realize they need to make structural changes to make a college education a value proposition rather than a black hole to throw money into.

Maybe.

I am not sure I have any answers, only that college was a 14-year experience for me (1978-1992) and I worked the whole time.  I think I got a better education and had a better (and less expensive) experience as a result, too.   Maybe if more companies can be induced (through tax credits) into hiring co-op students and interns, college could be more attractive, more relevant, and more cost-effective than in the past.

That, or maybe we need a new student center named after a wealthy alumni who contributed 10% of the construction cost.  Make sure it has a rock-climbing wall!  Or maybe a bouncy house!