Saturday, October 22, 2022

Families Shocked When Engine Replacement For Car Tops $10,000

Cars can be expensive to repair!
ONTARIO, CANADA - Some automobile owners, especially those with older models, have been shocked to find out how much it costs to replace their engines.

“I don't understand why they make the engine so expensive when you have to change it," Scarborough resident Karen Dolt said, who owns a 2018 KIA Soul.

Dolt’s SUV came with a warranty for the engine that covers 160,000 km, or eight years, whichever comes first.

Dolt said this year their vehicle clocked in more than 170,000 kilometres, which put them outside the warranty period when the engine failed.

When the engine wouldn't start, Dolt took it to her local dealership and was told it needed an engine replacement. With the new engine, labour and taxes, she said it would cost about $13,000.

Even though the vehicle was outside the warranty period, KIA agreed to pay for half the cost of a replacement engine.

“They won't fully cover the cost. They say the best they can do is half and half – I pay 50 per cent and they pay 50 per cent," said Dolt.

Kevin Klewlus of St. Catharines, Ont. bought a used 2011 Lincoln MKZ hybrid four years ago, and when the engine seized he was shocked to be told to replace it; with labour and taxes, it would cost about $10,000.

“At the dealership, he looked it up online and said you’re not going to like this. It was about $10,000 for the engine, plus labour and taxes,” he said.

Klewlus felt it’s not worth it to invest $10,000 in a car that is now over ten years old.

“I just wasn't expecting that kind of price to replace the engine,” he said.

At the University of Toronto Vehicle Research Centre, Director Olivier Obvious said complete engine failure is rare, and should not deter anyone from buying an automobile, as it is normal to have some engines fail when a product is mass produced.

Obvious adds the automotive engines being manufactured now are far superior to engines that were made a decade ago.

However, Obvious does say anyone considering a used car. or has an aging one, has to take into consideration the age of the engine and whether or not it is still under warranty.

“Those very unfortunate owners of cars that have to have their engines replaced, yes it will be very expensive. It all comes down to whether the degradation of the engine is within the warranty clause or not."

In Dolt’s case, she decided not to go ahead with the engine replacement and returned the car to her finance company. Dolt said she had been told by the company that it will be auctioned off, and she may be responsible for any difference owing.

CTV News Toronto reached out to KIA Canada regarding Dolt’s case, and a spokesperson said: “Kia Canada’s files indicate that on July 7, 2022, a Kia Canada Support Technician formally requested from the dealership, a copy of the results of its inspection and resulting diagnosis from the inspection of Ms. Dolt’s vehicle. Unfortunately, a response was not received from the dealership, indicating that the issue of disrepair had been resolved by the dealership, without the need [for] intervention by Kia Canada.”

“It is now apparent that Ms. Dolt's vehicle was not repaired. Further, we are advised that Ms. Dolt has relinquished the vehicle. Unfortunately, without access to the vehicle, Kia Canada is unable to comment on the diagnosis of the vehicle or status of the engine at the time of alleged failure.”

(c) 2022 Fun with Cut-n-Paste, Inc.
OK, so that was over the top.  But it illustrates how stupid this article from Canada is.  People think that replacing "the battery" in an electric vehicle is like replacing the batteries in their flashlight or the 12V battery in a conventional car.  wHy shOulD iT CoSt sO MuCh?

Well, here's the deal:  In an electric car, the battery is pretty much the whole car, just as an internal combustion engine is pretty much the whole car in a conventional vehicle.  You seize your engine after 150,000 miles, you have to think long and hard about whether to replace it or just junk the car and start over.

Sure, batteries are expensive.  So are engines and transmissions - and if either breaks, it pretty much junks any high-mileage cars.  Auction wholesale sites are full of "luxury" SUVs from Volvo, BMW, and Mercedes, with about 100K on the clock, but with the notation, "bad engine" or "bad transmission" - and they are sold for only a few thousand, if that.  When these things break, it costs more than the car is worth to fix.   This is not some unique problem to EVs - conventional cars have had it since the beginning.

Like with batteries, how long an IC engine lasts depends on how you treat it.  If you don't change the oil regularly, it won't last as long.  If you let it overheat, the heads will warp or the engine will seize.   If you beat the crap out of it doing donuts all day long, you can crap it out in a day.  Lithium-Ion batteries have similar issues.  If you run them down to zero many times, you may shorten their lifespan.  And even though they last a good long time, every battery has a lifespan.  Five years for the KIA Soul EV (which had a paltry 80-mile range) is inexcusable.  But 170K Km is a pretty good mileage to get out of an EV.  Ten years for a Lincoln Hybrid is more in line with the expected life expectancy of any vehicle.

Yes, cars are designed to run about 10 years and 150K miles or so.  Some go longer, some go less.  It depends on the laws of probability as well as how they are treated.  If you get mileage beyond that, consider yourself living on borrowed time.
 
Today's engines are pretty expensive to replace. The "Ecoboost" engine in my F150, with twin turbochargers, variable valve timing, direct injection, and a host of other goodies to squeeze every mile out of the last drop of fuel, can run as much as $10,000 to replace.

Yes, that is a lot less than $20,000 for an EV battery, but then again, the F150 is the most popular vehicle in America - they made millions of them.  And quite frankly, if I had 150,000 miles on my F150, and the engine seized, I would look to a junkyard for a replacement.   Plenty made, so plenty get wrecked and plenty of used engines available.

And yes, they pull batteries out of wrecked EVs as well - and sell them for a lot cheaper than the brand-new dealer price for one.  But the article doesn't touch on that.  And apparently neither of the whopping two people profiled bothered to check indepedent mechanics or junkyard replacements.

Dumber still, the lady profiled in the article doesn't bother to contact KIA Canada to appeal the decision by the zone office (offering only 50% of the replacement costs).  Instead, she hands over the keys to the finance company, who will bend her over for the difference.  How many years was that car loan, anyway?  Or did she buy it used?   Odds are, KIA Canada might have covered the whole cost (or at least more of it) if it was out of warranty by only 10K kilometers.  By the way 170K Km is a lot for a five-year-old hybrid!

One wonders if the problem wasn't apparent 10,000 Km ago - these sort of failures are not sudden, usually.

What irks me about this article is that it is just EV FUD - Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt.  I see this all the time online from trolls paid by the oil industry.  Since the Russian trolls are being scrubbed from most sites, they are more noticeable now.  One troll confidently predicts that EV batteries "only last a few years!" while some EVs and hybrids have been on the road now for hundreds of thousands of miles and over a decade with their original batteries.

It is like the latest episode of "Hoovies Garage" (which DOES NOT have a clickbait title at all!) about the Ford "Lightning" EV truck.  Hoovie is some rich kid whose Dad bought him a chain of taco stands, and now he hangs out in his mini-mansion-in-a-cornfield in some godforsaken flyover state and talks about his collection of fright pigs.  He intentionally sets out to buy, for example, the cheapest Ferrari on the market, with predictable results.  All his cars are high-mileage "drivers" that have a plethora of problems, but look cool in his garage.  And the guy can't turn a wrench or even replace a light bulb.

Worse yet, he is a car abuser.

So in his latest episode, he buys a brand-new "Lightning" and orders it with the smallest battery pack possible, which yields a pretty pathetic range to begin with (250 miles).  And of course, he drives it (and all his other cars) like a jerk - he seems to think that at every stoplight you have to burn rubber.  Watching him torture a vintage Jaguar XKE this way made me cringe - and vow to never watch his channel again.  They guy's an entitled know-nothing jerk.

He buys this low-range truck, charges it not all the way up and then puts a trailer behind it - punches the accelerator and then complains that the range isn't high enough.  It's just more EV FUD.

Like I said, I met a guy with a Tesla Model X towing a travel trailer and he was easily getting 150 miles per charge out of it - with a lot heavier trailer that was shaped like a box.   And since most campgrounds have 50A 220V service, it wasn't hard to recharge it in a matter of hours, when he stopped for the night.  But then again, he bought the extended-range battery pack.  He also adjusted his driving habits to suit that of the EV.

It reminds me of that case, a few years ago, where some lady bought a Honda hybrid and complained it would not get 50 MPG and went to small claims court to contest this.  Mileage depends on how you drive, and with hybrid cars, the whole point is to slow down before you hit that red light, so regenerative charging can recapture that kinetic energy and use it to recharge the batteries.  If you wait until you hit the crosswalk and use the service brakes to stop (converting that kinetic energy to heat and brake dust) your mileage will suck.

And if you did not understand that last paragraph, you have no business owning a hybrid or an EV and quite frankly, should not be driving any car at all.  Just sit at home and wait for Mr. Musk to send you a robotic Uber to take you into town.  We have too many shitty drivers on the road already!

But this illustrates the pitfalls of technology, particularly new technology.  We've seen with "social media" how people can be driven insane by conspiracy theories or have their bank accounts looted through phishing and other "social engineering" techniques.   People were just not ready for this and just not expecting it.  Today, we are more aware of these problems, but still, every day, stupid, ignorant, and uninformed people (as well as the elderly with dementia) are suckered in.

The same is true for hardware - particularly cars.  You've seen it on the road - people changing lanes without signaling - or looking!  People with five-year-old cars covered with dents, filthy with debris, and burning oil because they "forgot" (tee-hee!) to change it.   You can lead a horse to water, but with technology, there is little in the way of forgiveness.

Not mentioned in the article is the utter lack of required maintenance in an EV, other than brakes and tires.  No oil changes, no transmission fluid changes, no radiator fluid changes, no starter motors to replace - and so on and so forth.   So while batteries are expensive today - because few EVs are made, and none have a common battery design - there is an offset in reduced regular maintenance expenses, compared to a conventional car.

By the way, the punchline in the article, which is buried in the later paragraphs is this:
Ford of Canada directed Edwardson to work with his dealership on his engine issue, but Edwardson decided not to proceed with paying $20,000 to replace the battery. Edwardson is still able to drive his hybrid vehicle using just gasoline power
In other words, the car still runs and may run for many years more.  It is just that the hybrid feature is degraded.

And who in their right mind drives a Lincoln these days?

Friday, October 21, 2022

Radical Acceptance - Buzzwords or Good Advice?

Is radical acceptance just basic common sense, or some sort of new-age cult therapy?

I saw the comic above - which by the way is a great comic strip.  The punchline is always the same - Elly hates everything - but it never ceases to amaze me how the author has kept this up for some time now, and it never gets stale.  Well, so far, anyway.

But it got me to googling what "radical acceptance" is all about, and from what I can understand, it is part of something called dialectical behavior therapy, which sounds like some kind of capacitor.  The number of buzzwords had my Spidey-sense tingling as it sounded like a lot of "est" crapola.  I am not a big fan of cults or movements - most of them are bullshit.

The core idea, however, seems sound - and sort of what I have been preaching here for a decade now.  You have to accept things as they are - to some extent - or otherwise you drive yourself insane. 

For example, this student loan debacle.  Some kids signed up for tens of thousands of dollars in student loans for worthless degrees.  It was a shitty decision, but the only real option is to pay them back.  Sure, Biden is granting a $10,000 amnesty for some borrowers, but not wiping out all debts.  Maybe there will be more amnesty in the future - maybe not.  The problem with offering ten grand in amnesty is that it sets an expectation that future loans will be forgiven - which in turn causes some borrowers to make the rational decision to not pay their loans back and wait for loan forgiveness instead.

Externalization is the buzzword I like to use.  People complain that their personal problems are not personal problems at all, but part of an overall societal problem that requires a societal change to solve.  The problem isn't that they went to Party-U for four years and then got a worthless Master's Degree in "Communications" from Professor Click.  No, the problem is that college should have been free the whole time and that student loans should be discharged in bankruptcy!

We tried the latter tactic before.  The net result was grad students walked away from massive debts whole living high on the hog in grad school.  So that loophole was closed, and just to make sure, our Republican friends decided that private student loans should be bankruptcy-proof as well.  With that guarantee in place, the banks started lending ridiculous amounts of money to kids who could never realistically pay it back.  As a result, some become perpetual debtors, or spend a good portion of their lives paying it all back.

Average student loan debt is only about  30 grand, however.  I had $38,000 in student loan debt (over $80,000 in today's dollars) and yes, I paid it all back.  I was almost 50 by the time I made the last payment, too!  So for all you naysayers claiming "You don't understand...." - I do.

But then again, I borrowed for an Engineering degree and a Law degree - not some bullshit degree in "Communications" or "Ethnic Studies" or "Anthropology" or whatever. If you want to study that fluff crap (and no, this is not up for debate, it is fluff crap) then go to a Community college or other cheap school.  Spending a hundred grand on a stupid degree is not my problem - it is yours.

But I guess I have to "accept" that people are blithering idiots and want to blame all their problems on society at large.  And by and large, I have pretty much come to accept that.  In fact, I have realized over the years that pining for perfection in the world is pretty stupid and a waste of time.  And it will drive you insane - quite literally.

Take my friend Tim.  Tim was a few years older than me and he liked to smoke an awful lot of pot.  He sort of floated through High School and stopped taking math courses in the 9th grade because they were hard.  Well, that and pot.  He dumped science in favor of "humanities" even though he was quite good in his science courses.  He went to a liberal arts college and majored in - you guessed it - "Communications" - a major that means absolutely nothing whatsoever.

He would get really high and then rail about the unfairness of the world.  Everything was stacked against him!  It was all so unfair!  The politicians were corrupt!  The "Corporations, Man!" were evil.  Even the corporation who paid his Dad a hefty salary that allowed him to graduate with no student loan debt - all evil, vile, and banal.  It always shocked him that people acted in their own best interests and not in the best interests of society at large.

When I went to work at GM, he stopped talking to me.  I had "sold out to the evil Corporations" who were paying my way though school - and a salary and health insurance to boot.  If you get a chance, I highly suggest you "sell out" - as most people end up doing.  It's not such a bad gig.  Quite good, in fact.

As you might guess, he was chronically unemployed or underemployed and moved back in with his parents.  His girlfriend left him, after years of this nonsense, as she wanted to settle down and raise a family - and an unemployed husband wasn't going to cut it.  Of course, this gave Tim a chance for introspection and reflection on where he was going with his life.

Ha-ha.  Just kidding.  Tim doubled-down his bet and said his girlfriend was "just interested in money, like all the bitches!" and smoked more pot. Once again, life dealt him a shitty hand and nothing he could have done would have altered the outcome.

I could go on and on, but you get the idea.  Rather than accept the world as it was and work with what was and is, he sat in the corner and pouted, like a petulant child, and refused to do anything until the world was re-ordered to his tastes.  Of course, that would never happen, so it gave him an excuse to live in stasis.  Well, until his parents booted him out of the house.  Everyone was fortunate that he hadn't started collecting firearms at this point.

Now, some would argue that such "radical acceptance" would allow evil to continue in the world, and without dissent and protest and activism, nothing would ever change for the better.   And there is a nugget of truth in that. But as Dr. Sol Gordon advised me, nearly 40 years ago, the best thing I could do for myself and society was to succeed.  Because successful people are the ones who enact real change in the world, not losers who whine about how unfair everything is and do nothing to change it, for themselves or society at large.

And to some extent, this is what has happened in the last 50 years or so.  Our generation won, as I noted before.  We enacted social changes that were unheard of in the history of mankind.  So much has changed since my childhood that it is unbelievable.  And this change occurred not because people sat in the corner and pouted, or because they chanted slogans and held up signs, but because they took control of the reins and levers of power.

This is not to say there isn't so much more to be done.  Things like racial equality, equality for the sexes, and sexual liberation have come a long way - and have a longer way to go.  But to deny we have made progress simply because it isn't perfect yet is a slap in the face of our predecessors who fought - and often died - for these causes.

The world can be a pretty shitty place.  People are greedy and selfish - by default.  As a species, we seem to do things to insure our extinction.  But on the other hand, "our better angels" sometimes come to the forefront and we try, at least, to do the right thing.

But on a personal level, acceptance of things-as-they-are is so important to being active in your own life.  The person who rails against unfairness - but does nothing to advance his own cause - is falling victim to learned helplessness.  Once you give up on even trying, nothing good will ever happen in your life.

In Alcoholic's Anonymous (or any 12-step program) they have a "serenity prayer" which pretty much sums up the whole concept of "radical acceptance" very concisely:

God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change,
The courage to change the things I can,
And the wisdom to know the difference.

Pretty silly prayer, but then again, it sums it up neatly.  We do have control over some aspects of our lives, but fate plays a big role as well. We can give up on what little control we have and "cast ourselves to the fates" but that rarely works out well.  Railing against fate is futile. 

Oddly enough, I am reading a biography of Machiavelli, who wrote The Prince.  People have weird ideas about Machiavelli, thinking he is this hard-assed dude who said things like "It is better to be feared than to be loved" - which he did say, as advice to a "Prince" or leader.  He wrote  The Prince after being imprisoned and tortured as being a suspected traitor.  He wrote the book hoping it would be an entree back into his life as a diplomat.  It was never "published" in his lifetime, but rather he showed to some important people, hoping they would hire him as a result.

One of the interesting aspects of his book is that he acknowledges that fate plays a big hand in the fortune of leaders, but that choices and actions play a large part as well.  Or as he put it, how you handle fate determines how successful you are.  When opportunity comes knocking, you have to at least answer the door.

All that being said, I understand where Elly is coming from.  Well, first, since she "hates everything" (which is her mantra) I suspect she is depressed and "hating everything" is her way to dealing - or not dealing - with reality.  But moreover, I am always suspect of seminars and meetings where someone stands up (particularly with a dorky microphone like that) and tells people that all their problems are their own fault.  If only they would "accept" reality, everything would fall into place!

Well, that is a bit of an oversimplification of "radical acceptance" but it does point out that there is a little bit of "blame-the-victim" in it.  Some people are indeed cast to the fates and get the shitty end of the stick, again and again.  The law of probability - if nothing else - tells is that such folks will exist in any society.

Accepting reality as it is won't, by itself, make you happy or successful.  That will take a lot of other things as well - including luck.  But to quote Edna Mode, "Luck favors the prepared, darling!"  And those who can perceive reality more clearly than others tend to be more successful in the world.

And that, in a nutshell (pardon the pun) is why these Trumpers and Qanonsense people and Antifarts are so unhappy and angry.  Their personal lives are a trainwreck, and then want to externalize all of their problems. They literally are willing to sacrifice their lives and livelihoods to follow a political cause.  Imagine if the MyPillowGuy kept his mouth shut and sold pillows instead.  He could have cashed out and lived on a yacht for the rest of his life.  Instead, he will end up bitter and broke, throwing his life away for a politcal figure who doesn't care if he lives or dies.

On a personal level, some folks argue that "radical acceptance" is nothing more than "blame-the-victim" for their own traumas in life.  You had a traumatic childhood - get over it!  See?  All better now!   But I think that is an oversimplification or a misinterpretation as to what it is all about.  Shit happens in life, and accepting that doesn't mean you are validating it or thinking it is good or great.  But it can help you move on from the "what ifs" in life that drive everyone nuts.

Late at night, if I get up to go pee (this will happen to you, more than once a night, as you get older) if I don't go back to bed right away, the brain starts ruminating as to how I could have lived my life better if I had a "do-over".  Suppose I could go back in time and make different decisions?   Buy Microsoft stock instead of a motorcycle.  Save my paper-route money instead of spending it on candy.  Put more money into the 401(k) instead of remodeling the kitchen.  Borrow less in student loans.  Not get into credit card debt - the list is endless and the human brain is relentless with "what ifs" late at night.

There is a reason our brains do this, I think - as well as dream.  It is the neural network of our brain training itself with new nodal weighting values.  We learn from our earlier mistakes, and regretting our past actions maybe is a way of programming our brains not to make the same mistakes again.  Yes, I have regrets in life - I have to accept that, for better or worse.  But, it does not mean I am doomed to repeat the same mistakes over and over again until I am dead.

That, in short, is the problem with not accepting the past and moving on.  You are doomed to repeat it, over and over again.

So maybe there is a nugget - a nugget - of value in this "radical acceptance" buzzword nonsense.  Don't take it as a personal assault or criticism, but just gentle advice to accept things as they are and move on with the present and the future.  Because no matter how bad things were - or are - giving up on the future isn't the answer.

Thursday, October 20, 2022

Wealth Inequality, Revisited Again

People say we should share the wealth.  But what is wealth, anyway, and is there really anything to share?

On the Internet, I hear statistics all the time that 10 people own 50% of the world's wealth or some such nonsense. I say nonsense because often these statistics count only equities such as stocks, so when they say "wealth" they are talking about stock portfolios and the illusion of market cap.

As Elon Musk's recent travails illustrate, (or that of Mark Zuckerberg) market cap is nonsense.  People said he was the "richest person in the world" based on the market cap of the shares he holds in Tesla and other companies.  But when Tesla stock tanked by a third, where did all the money go?  The answer is, it never went anywhere because it never existed - it was just market valuation based on what the last sucker paid in, for one share of Tesla, multiplied by the number of outstanding shares.

It is like the value of your house (which will be sinking soon, if not already).  A house is "worth" $500,000 in 2007 and in 2009 it is "worth" only $250,000.  Where did all the money go?  Answer: Nowhere because a house is not money.  The "money" never existed.  It was just an appraisal of value.  Until you sell the property and put cash in your pocket, it is just a theory.  So when you read about so-and-so being "worth" a billion dollars (Hello, Yeezy?) you have to be skeptical.  Chances are, their "net worth" is based on appraised values of real estate and stocks they own.  Real worth - in terms of cash, would be far less, if they cashed-out of their positions.

Regardless of valuations, some people argue that this "wealth" should be "redistributed" to the poor (meaning them) which is an interesting proposition.  Assuming we could declare martial law and take away all of Elon Musk's stock, when we sold it, well, the share price would plummet - as it does when he sells his shares.  So we would not realize all of that "wealth" that he had, if we were to redistribute it.  Even taking it through onerous taxation would have the same result.

Even if we redistributed all his "net worth" ($230 Billion) to everyone in the United States (screw the rest of the world, right?) it would give each of us a one-time check of about $696.  I don't know about you, but that would change my life - forever! I could open that new cupcake shop I always dreamed about, or kick my meth habit and become a Nun.  We're talking about life-changing events!

But of course, when everyone gets that check, merchants will conveniently offer products priced at $696 until the money runs out.  And as we have seen in recent years, when you throw "free money" into the economy, well, it just raises inflation, which pretty much wipes out any increase in wealth.  The "stimulus" checks of the pandemic era were just an advance on our pay in 2022 - paid back in terms of inflation.

But let's look at the other argument - why not pay employees more and pay CEOs less? That is the argument unions make when companies claim they are broke and cannot hand out raises.  If we assume Mr. Musk has an annual income of $2400 Million (hard to calculate as he is as crafty as Trump with his bookkeeping!) and we divide that by the approximately 100,000 employees of Tesla (I could not find numbers for SpaceX or other ventures he owns or controls) that does come to a tidy $24,000 per employee.  Not a bad raise - but it presumes Mr. Musk is now making zero dollars a year.

You could play this game with any Billionaire. Jeff Bezos makes about $1.7 million a year (He's one of the "poors" I guess, or is better at hiding income!) and has about 1.5 million employees (!!) to pay.  As you can see, his "income" would only give each employee a dollar-a-year raise, which isn't going to change anything for anybody.  But again, we are looking at income, not wealth.  And I suspect a lot of his "income" like Elon Musk's, is untaxable "loans" taken out against his stock holdings.   It gets tricky to do these calculations.

So maybe we should tax Mr. Musk or Mr. Bezos instead?  They should pay for their "fair share" of government programs and defense budget and so forth.   I agree with you there - but realize that the tax antics of Billionaires are just a delaying move - borrowing against his shares to avoid taxes, which will have devastating consequences when the bills actually come due.  In fact, Musk has already had to deal with this - selling shares of Tesla to pay back loans.  What happens if Tesla shares tank between the time he takes out the loans and pays them back?  And I suspect, like margin loans, the banks can force share sales when the price goes below a target value - which in turn would depress share prices further.

Tax avoidance can be a dangerous game to play!

So let's say we take away all his money and give it to the government.  While $230 Billion sounds like a lot of dough, it pales in comparison to the $5.35 trillion the government spends every year.  This one time cash payment would cover about 4.29% of the Federal Government's budget for one year only.  If we taxed 100% of his real income, it would amount to a fraction of a percent.

Wealth inequality is a bad thing, economically - wealth that is tied up in the hands of a few people can cause a economy to stagnate. A healthy and wealthy middle-class is necessary for an economy to thrive.  You need customers for your $100,000 electric SUVs or you'll go broke, too!

But the idea that "taking away" or "redistributing" the wealth of the very rich is going to solve all our problems is, well, nonsense.  And of course, legally, we cannot do this, even if we wanted to.

Tax reform is a good idea - but the amount of income it will generate for the government isn't going to necessarily balance the budget.  And an awful lot of that increased income is going to come from people who consider themselves middle-class or upper-middle-class, who are already paying close to 50% of their income in Federal, State, and local taxes.  Your local doctor or dentist or car dealer is the one getting socked with these tax bills, not the high-flying rich who own their own jets.

But once again, people - and the media - confuse "wealth" with "income" and conflate the two.  As wage-slaves, we plebes only understand income - our weekly paychecks, which we spend as quickly as possible on basic survival needs such as food, clothing, shelter, cars, tattoos, piercings, and of course, video games and drugs.  We don't have enough money - or discipline - to set aside any money to "invest" and create wealth.  And even if we did, we end up "buying" a bogus investment such as gold, bitcoin, nfts, or whatever other get-rich-quick scam comes down the pike.  And when it all blows up in our faces, we pine for "redistributing the wealth" and then go online to Amazon and drown our sorrows in consumerism and hand another penny or a dollar to a Billionaire.

And these same poor folks will vote for Republicans, who promise to slash Medicare and Social Security and of course, cut-off aid to Ukraine and let Putin win (and he will be satisfied with that and promise not to invade anyone else!).  Cutting spending is indeed another way to balance the budget, but for some reason, these cuts are always directed at the poor - no one is saying that those PPP loans should be paid back!  And weirdly enough, it is the poor that vote to cut their own programs.   I guess masochism runs deep among the poor - they think they deserve to be treated like crap.

If I sound jaded, it is because I am.  After blogging for over a decade and approaching 5,000 postings, it is interesting to go back in time and read my blog from a decade ago.  Back then, we were recovering from the delusions that bankrupted many a baby-boomer who got caught in the something-for-nothing mentality and thought their houses were gold mines.

You'd think their kids would have observed this and realized their parents were idiots.  Well, they did, but the next generation just lurched off at a different get-rich-quick scheme, all to the cry of "This time, it's different!" which, by the way, is one sure way to tell if something is a scam or not.

But those halcyon days seem so innocent and pure compared to today.  Back then, we could at least figure out what went wrong and people - for the most part - acknowledged their own malfeasance.  Well, some did. Others externalized on a massive scale and started subscribing to wilder and wilder conspiracy theories.  Baby boomers who "lost it all" to the housing collapse of 2008 were prime meat for Trumpism and Qanonsense in 2016 and today.

And why not?  Telling people hard truths is never a fun job.  You tell people they are fools and spendthrifts and they will lynch you.  You tell them they are "beautiful" and that "but for" those immigrants and colored people and trans folks, they would be rich, rich, rich! - and you are elected President, at least by the electoral college.

And when it all comes apart, they lose their minds.  The dream of free ponies is too beautiful to let die! Yet the fail to realize that all the free-pony schemes in the past always came apart - hurting the little people the worst.  Whether it is Communism or Fascism, the net result is the same - entire countries reduced to ruin.

There is, I think, a middle-way, between the extremes, that would largely solve most, but not all, of our problems.  But no one wants to hear about that.  Half the country thinks Biden is too radical, and half think he is too conservative.

Me, as Goldilocks, thinks that's just about right.

There is an election in a couple of weeks.  It will be interesting to see how people vote.  Will the plebes really vote to abolish Social Security and Medicare - just to "own the libs?"  Stranger things have happened in history!

Wednesday, October 19, 2022

Lifetime Guarantee!

One nice thing about getting old, you clean up on those lifetime guarantees!

When I was a kid, they would advertise things with a "lifetime guarantee!" and people would be induced to buy things because of that.  For example, the muffler shop would offer a "lifetime guarantee!" on mufflers.  There was a catch though - actually, more than one.

Only the muffler was guaranteed, not the pipes connected to it, or the hangers and clamps.  So if the pipes rusted out and dragged the muffler on the ground, too bad.  Also, pipes tended (back then) to rust out before the mufflers.

Yes, back in the "good old days" of the muscle car era, exhaust systems were made largely of mild steel - which rusted almost immediately.  If you got three years out of an exhaust system, it was a miracle.  Few companies used aluminized mufflers or pipes, none used stainless.  With the advent of emissions controls in the late 1970's, the government mandated that the emissions equipment had to last 50,000 miles (and be warranted for that time), so suddenly, the automakers discovered aluminized steel, galvanized steel, and of course stainless. 

At first, they would only use these materials from the header to the catalytic converter - and then mild steel from there to the tailpipe.  Today, well, exhaust systems can last a decade or more, even in corrosive environments - which is why "aftermarket" exhaust systems are an utter waste of money.  The "Muffler Shop" of yore is either gone, or they morphed into tire/brake shops.  The old days, where you would go to a muffler shop and there would be hundreds of exhaust pipes hanging from the ceiling, like a forest of metal, are gone for good.

But I digress.

The big reason that few people collected on these "lifetime guarantees" was that statistically, people traded their cars in every three years or so, back in the 1960's.  That was the length of a car loan back then, and after three years and 36,000 miles, a car was starting to look ratty.  I recall reading an article back then that the muffler people did a survey on this and noted that most people sold or traded their car withing six months of installing a new muffler.  By then, itt was ready for new tires (bias ply, of course!) and a new battery (36 month!) and a new exhaust system.  People got tired of paying for repairs, so most people traded-in.  And as a result, they never were able to cash-in on these "lifetime guarantees" on mufflers, shocks, or whatever.

A few people did.  I recall talking to one fellow who claimed his Dad got three "free" mufflers out of Sears, because he kept his old Chevy for ten years.  Ten years!  The car must have had close to 100,000 miles on it!  Can you imagine that?  No one keeps a car that long - or did, back then.  But even Dad didn't get away with much - odds are, they charged him for the clamps and pipes (which they would claim needed replacement) and hey, while you're in here, how about an oil change and a tuneup?  And have you replaced the transmission fluid lately?  Rotated the tires?

You see, the "lifetime guarantee" is also a marketing gambit to get repeat business and also lock a customer in to one provider.  Sort of like a loyalty program, I guess.

So, why didn't the muffler company make a stainless-steel or aluminized muffler and make it last forever?  They'd never have to pay out on the guarantee!  Well, as you might imagine, a guy with a three-year-old car (halfway worn out, in 1965!) didn't want to spend much on a muffler. And a guarantee was as good as a product that would last forever.  So, you could have made a super-duper muffler that would last a lifetime, but it would cost so much no one would buy it. Printing out a "Lifetime guarantee" brochure cost only pennies, however.  And of the thousands of mufflers you sold, only a handful were ever replaced under the guarantee, as most people sold their cars within months of replacing the muffler.

Anyway, that was back in the day.  A few places still have "lifetime guarantees" but over the years, these have been watered down a bit, and some of them are pretty flimsy.  Here are some of my experiences with "Lifetime guarantees" that I have had in the past.

Bilstein - Shock Absorbers.  I have put Bilstein shocks on a number of vehicles - even a motorhome. They are a good product, and back in the day when the only other choice were skinny little shock absorbers from the dealer or the local parts store, they were the cat's ass. And they were guaranteed for life.

I only had to replace one pair, on my 1995 F150.  The rear end was getting a little bouncy after 100,000 miles with those shocks, so I called their 1-800 number.  They had, in the past, mailed out new shocks, no questions asked, to people claiming their shocks were busted.  It was more of a hassle for them to get the old shocks back and examine them than it was worth.  But, as you might imagine, folks started abusing this system.  They would claim their shocks were bad and get a free set, which they would then sell on eBay or Craigslist, or just use on another car.  Or maybe they never bought Bilsteins in the first place!

So when I called, they explained I would have to mail in my old shocks, to have them examined.  And since I could not drive around with no shock absorbers, I bought a new pair from them in the interim.  I mailed back the old pair - at my expense as I recall - and a month later, I did get a credit on my credit card.  So they still stood behind their product, they just stopped being chumps about it.

And many other companies have had the same experience.  Many require original sales receipts, which most people don't keep for ten years, much less a lifetime.  It is one reason why I put all receipts for vehicle stuff in a binder for that vehicle.  It helps me keep track of what work was done on it (handy for resale as well) and came in handy with lifetime guarantees as well.

Tilley - Hats.  Tilley makes hats, including their original "Endurable" Cotton Duck T3 hat.  We bought two of their hats at Oshkosh back in the 1990's, so we've had them for like 30 years.  Mark's started to get shabby - sweat stained and the grommets corroded.  The hat started to disintegrate, probably as a result of being bleached too often.  I mailed in the hat and they sent us a new one - that was about five years ago.

This year, my hat finally reached the point of no return.  Today, you have to submit your claim online, and perhaps submit photos of the damage to the hat and also photos to confirm you destroyed the old hat (lest someone else use it to claim a free hat!).  And they are clear that only the "Guaranteed for Life!" hats are guaranteed for life.  This leaves me with the impression that not all their hats are guaranteed for life anymore, if in fact any of them are.

When we bought these hats, I think that was their only product, or at least, one of a few hats that they made.  Today, they sell whole lines of hats in all sorts of colors (other than "natural") as well as clothing.  As you might expect, the company was sold - then re-sold - and now the hats are made in China.

So maybe the lifetime guarantee is off the table.  But during their heyday, they honored it.  I filled out the online form for my hat, and we'll see where that goes.  I'll update the posting if they send me a new hat or not.

Yakima - Bicycle Racks.  There used to be two high-end fussy bike-rack companies - Yakima and Thule.  Yakima had round bars, Thule had square ones.  Like Apple versus Android, you picked a universe and lived in it.  Over the years, we bought and sold many Yakima items as we bought and sold bicycles, canoes, and kayaks, and fitted the racks to various vehicles, from cars to trucks to campers to trailers.  We bought a Yakima "Rocket Box" to haul things in as well.  And over the years, we've bought a few Thule items, as well as from up-and-coming producer Rhino Racks (from down under!) and some generic wanna-be things from Walmart.

The Yakima and Thule stuff isn't cheap, but it fits perfectly and interacts with factory rack mounts.  Many people balk at the cost of these racks and then buy some cheap rack at Walmart which attaches to their trunklid and scratches the paint and dumps their bicycle on the road at the first pothole (we've seen it, in our travels - bicycles mangled as they are run over by big trucks).

So yea, Yakima and Thule stuff is expensive, but you'll have it forever, you can always sell it on Craigslist or Facebook marketplace or whatever, and it is flexible and adaptable to different vehicles and different items to carry.  And Yakima racks are guaranteed for life.  To the original purchaser only!  Save those receipts!

Well, sort of.  We have two "old school" Yakima bike racks that we bought back in 1999 when we bought the two TREK bicycles.  You have to remove the front wheel (which locks onto another rack) and the front fork locks into a "head" while the rear wheel rides in a channel and straps in place.   They worked well, provided you don't mind removing the front wheel all the time.

We had another kind, which let you keep the wheel on, but clamped to the frame.  It worked OK, too, but scratched the paint on the frame.  Plus it rode very high.  I sold those to a neighbor when I no longer needed them.

Well, so far, so good.  I had some experience with their "lifetime" warranty as our kayak saddles had rubber inserts that, after a decade, started to rot away.  I called their 1-800 number and the "dude" who answered the phone cheerfully sent me a new set.   Far-out!

A few years later, the plastic latch on the bicycle rack "head" cracked and I called again.  Once again, they sent out a new part (the head) for free.  What a company!  Stands behind their products!

Well, two years later, the latch on the other head cracked (plastic, again) and I called Yakima.  They told me they no longer made that product and thus could not send me a replacement head.  They helpfully offered to sell me a new rack, however.

So,"lifetime" means lifetime of the product, not my lifetime.   And you can understand why they might want to take that stance.  Since the products last a long time, they change hands frequently and someone can buy the product, broken, for cheap, and then claim it broke under their stewardship, and get a new one - for a fraction of the cost!  Sweet deal - but one that could bankrupt a company, over time.  Lifetime guarantees are easy to make when you have been in business only a few years.  Over time, they add up to a staggering liability.

L.L.Bean, the overpriced Maine woods outfitter, ran into this same problem.  Their boots and jackets and whatnot were "guaranteed for life" and what's more, their return policy was generous.  You could return a product for any reason and get store credit.  So wily shoppers went to garage sales and whatnot and snapped up anything with an L.L.Bean label on it, and then took it to the store for a "return" and credit, and pretty soon, you have enough store credit to buy a canoe - for a fraction of the cost!

So, as you might imagine, L.L.Bean started reining-in their policy.  Want to return it?  Sure, let me see your sales receipt!  Returns are only authorized for original purchasers.  And I am sure that, over time, they will tighten this policy even further.  For example, they now allow returns for any reason only for one year.  After that, well, it better be defective, not just worn out.  And to prove you are within one year, well, you need that receipt.

That is another reason why few people collect on Lifetime Guarantees - laziness or forgetfulness.  You have an old hat and it gets grungy - you throw it out without thinking about it.  You forgot about the lifetime guarantee, or it seems like too much hassle to pack up the hat and ship it to Canada (as I did with Mr. See's hat).  So you go out and buy a new hat.  Statistically, few people collect on these deals, mostly because they don't bother to ask.

One reason why stores request a driver's license when you return something is so they can track who is returning.  Amazon does this as well and "bans" users who buy things and then return them.  People were actually buying wedding dresses, getting married, and then returning them when done.  Saves the bride a couple of grand, but costs Amazon (or the seller) the same amount - no one will pay top dollar for a used wedding dress.

So when Walmart asks me for a driver's license, it is to track how many times I return things.  If I become a serial returner, well, they will suspect something is up and ban me as well.

I recounted before how I was at a Lowe's once, and this crackhead lady wanted to return a $200 faucet (why are faucets so freaking expensive, anyway?  Subject for a new posting, as I will need new faucets shortly).   They were just starting to put RFID chips in the high-value products and the guy at the return desk told the lady she couldn't return the item because their inventory control system showed the item as being on the shelf.  RFID chips can not only detect when an item is carried out without paying, but attach individual serial numbers to products, so as to identify stolen goods.

The guy was flat-out calling the lady a thief, without saying so.  She tried to argue, but finally realized what he was saying.  And when the clerk made noises about the police, she left the store.

Stolen goods are another source of "returns" as well, which is, unfortunately, another reason why these "lifetime guarantees" are fading from the scene.

So, "Lifetime Guarantees" may become a thing of the past - or are becoming a thing of the past, as, over time, every company that offers them, accumulates more and more liability for every product they sell.  Eventually, it could bankrupt the company.  So save those receipts - companies are being more strict with these guarantees - if they offer them at all.

UPDATE:  Tilley claims that unless the words "Lifetime Guarantee" appear on the label, it isn't covered.  Here is the label - they claim I can get it replaced even if it just wears out - and I should leave it in my will!  In other words, a perpetual guarantee - even to my descendants!  We'll see if they honor this or not...

The hat label - is this a "Lifetime Guarantee or not?"

Quite frankly, I understand the business case here.  I bought these hats 30 years ago from a predecessor company.  They already replaced one.  Why replace the other?  It is a total loss for them.  And do "Lifetime Guarantees" really sell goods anymore?  Which would you rather have, a $25 hat with no guarantee, or a $100 hat with a guarantee?  Odds are, four $25 hats will last you a lifetime.  And you don't have to hassle with guarantees, filling out forms, or saving receipts!

UPDATE:  They agreed to replace the hat (Currently selling for $99) but there is a $20 "processing fee" to cover shipping and handling, plus $1.20 in tax (?).  Considering these are now made in China, well, they are at worst, breaking even, I think!  Still, $99 hat for $20 - or am I being a chump, here?  It will be interesting to see if the new hat has the "Lifetime Guarantee" or not.....

UPDATE:  The new hat arrived today, five days after I submitted the claim.  It is nice and the "olive" color shows stains less.  The new hat does not have "Lifetime Guarantee" or any such language in the label.  There was cardboard tag attached saying it has a lifetime guarantee, and it suggested I register the hat with them within 60 days of purchase.  But when I went to their site to register it, the page only shows claims - no registration.  Oh, well, the last hat lasted nearly 30 years.  I doubt I will need a new one by age 92....

Monday, October 17, 2022

Cazenovia College Daze

Small, Liberal Arts, all-female schools are going bankrupt or struggling,  Why?

A reader sends me a link to an article about my old hometown - although after 40-some-odd years, it hardly feels like a hometown anymore, just a place I used to live.  I've spent more time away than there, and arguably have more roots in Northern Virginia than Central New York.

Anyway, a small college is going bust and it isn't hard to figure out why.  It was a small, liberal arts college, originally for women only.  Many of these small schools were founded many years ago, usually by Fathers who wanted a place for their daughters to get an education - in an era where women were not welcome (or safe) on mostly-male college campuses.  Not much has changed over the years, it seems.

So, for example, Wells College, founded by one of the founders of Wells-Fargo, was a small, liberal arts college in Aurora New York, near where our lake house was.  Like Cazenovia College, Wells College was on the brink of insolvency, but fortunately one of their alumni was the creator of "American Girl" dolls, which she sold to Mattel for nearly a Billion dollars - and she has supported Wells College with that largess.

The folks at Caz College need to go through their Alumni directory and look for Billionaires!

But it is an old story and one that will be replicated in the coming years - and one I predicted early on in this blog.  Like GM in the late 1970's, small colleges are selling an overpriced product that is, quite frankly, shoddy.  A degree in agitation studies from no-name U isn't going to set you up for a job.  And yes, education for education's sake is fine and all, but not when it costs $200,000 in borrowed money.

Yea, that. The tuition, room, and board at Cazenovia College was listed in the article as over $50K a year.  If you assume 1,000 students there (which they no longer have) that comes to $50 Million a year in income.  Surely this is enough to service a $25M debt, right?

Well, no.  First of all, they have fewer than 1000 students today - in fact, around 700.  When I left Syracuse University, they had over 20,000 students - today about 22,000.  Places like Penn State have close to 100,000.  That's a small city!  So 700 students - the ratio of students to faculty is very low, which is good from an educational standpoint, but bad from an economic one.

The school realizes what is going on.  Demographics is the key - and what I mentioned in my first posting about college bankruptcies.   Fewer high school graduates are available as the next generation is smaller than the last.   And of those graduates, if they want to spend $50K a year on an education, they want an education that is relevant to today's needs, and from a "name brand" university.  You don't want to go to a job interview and the first question you get is, "Cazenovia College - where is that, exactly?  Is that like a Community College or something?  Do they have a football team?"

Yea, that's unfair.  But it is a realistic scenario - and you can't fight reality.   Recruiters and HR people look for name-brand colleges, often aware of them only because of the sports teams.  I cannot tell you how many job interviews I went to where, when I mentioned I went to S.U., they talked about Coach Boeheim for a half-hour.  Only the real tech geeks appreciated that I went to General Motors Institute - that landed me a job at Carrier.

The same is true with The George Washington University.  Yes, "The" is part of the title.  Actually it was "The National Law Center at The George Washington University" - try to fit that on a team jersey!  And when I went there, there were none.  Well, we had an intramural team, I think, but the new Dean made it a goal to create an NCAA Level 1 or whatever basketball team, and he did - using our law school tuition money to attract key talent.  So when I went on job interviews after graduation, it was "Hey, what about those Colonials!"  People are blithering idiots.

So we have a perfect storm - admissions are down and tuition is up, and liberal arts degrees from small colleges are a hard-sell.  Worse yet, is not every student is paying that $50K a year to go there.  When I was a teenager, we used to hang out  at the "Rathskeller" or whatever they called it - a small bar underneath the dining hall, as I recall, with pool tables, some pinball machines, a juke box, and of course, draft beer.

It was a different era back then - before the 21-year drinking age.  I was about 16 at the time, and we would hang out with the college girls and drink beer and play pool, and sometimes these girls would invite me back to their dorm rooms for a little nooky.   Yes, shocking, I know.  I was seduced by older women!  Pretty desperate women, I guess.

But all that being said, some of the girls I met were there on scholarships.  They weren't paying full-boat tuition or anything close to it.  And with all the partying we did, well, some of them dropped out before graduating.  It was the 1970's and a lot of pot was involved as well.

So although the sticker price is $50K a year, hardly anyone actually pays that. So their income is far less than what you would think.

Note that Cazenovia College was named "one of the best colleges" by U.S. News and World Report.  Still think those rankings mean shit?  I never did.

The people running the college are trying their best to make it work.  They started admitting men, as did Wells college.  And maybe they can turn things around, as Sweetbriar College (my late sister's Alma Mater) apparently is doing.  The new President of that college has radically restructured the curriculum.  Whether this works, long-term, remains to be seen.  It helped that the "Save Sweetbriar" alums kicked in $12M as part of the deal.

But like anything else, something has to give.  GM made shitty cars back in the 1970s, but they are still around today - after bankruptcy, of course.  Stripping away a lot of debt and restrictive labor contracts (as well as cutting costs and closing unprofitable divisions) was the key.  And I think colleges are no different.  Sure, they are academic institutions, but they are also businesses, and have to at least cover their costs, or go bust.  Even if run by the government, there has to be a lid on costs, lest the taxpayers revolt.

And maybe, like with Sweetbriar, the threat of extinction will get some alumni to open up their pocketbooks and cough up enough dough to keep the place running.   After all, $3M shouldn't be too hard to raise.  Heck, even $25M isn't all that difficult.

Stay tuned!